Search

SEDAN BUYING GUIDE

Best cars for commuters 2012

Elon Musk could save the world. Or at least revolutionize your morning drive.

The Tesla and SpaceX founder released his $109,000 electric Roadster last year, but a new project, the Model S sedan, could be the perfect thing for eco-minded commuters:  its 85 kWh motor has a range of 300 miles on one charge and will go 0-60mph in 4.4 seconds, he says.

2013 Ford Fusion Hybrid2013 Ford Fusion HybridAdd in a plush Nappa leather interior, seven-speaker sound system and 17-inch center console (it looks like an iPad), and you might even start to look forward to those mornings spent enduring exhaust fumes on the 405.
 
Musk, for his part, says the car itself will be much more than just endurable.

"You want people to buy the car because it is the best car," he says. "You don't want them saying, I'm going to accept something else just because it's electric."

The best part about it? After tax rebates, the base version Model S will cost less than $50,000, with the performance version costing $79,900.

Unfortunately, it won't be available until later this year—and there's a considerable waiting list. Until then, consider the Toyota Prius, Chevrolet Volt, or Ford Fusion for weekday jaunts. Along with six others, they made our list of the year's best cars for commuting.

Behind the Numbers

Scion xDScion xDTo determine our list we started with new vehicles listed as Consumer Reports "Recommended Picks" for this year. Recommended Picks are models that have average or better predicted reliability and that meet Consumer Reports' safety standards; they also had to have performed well in accelerating, braking, handling, comfort and other user-oriented tests.

Then we selected from that group those vehicles that earned the "Most Reliable" distinction for this year—and crosschecked them with CR's "Most Fuel-Efficient" winners as well. Nine vehicles, including hybrids, sedans and even a couple SUVs, made the final cut.

One interesting note: We didn't put a price limit on the contenders, since there are cars at any MSRP that will facilitate a decent drive to work—and, let's face it, we'd all rather drive a fly ride than a bargain-basement beater. Interestingly enough, all of our finalists cost well under $40,000. And if you remove the hybrids, which carry a hefty premium for their advanced technology, they all cost less than $23,000.

In fact, hybrids are not necessarily more efficient than their conventional counterparts. Just ask Johan de Nysschen, the head of Audi of America. He says that discrepancy is precisely why Audi is pursuing diesel engines more fervently than hybrid tech.

"If we look at the A8, for example, today a gasoline-powered V8 4.2 A8 with 372 horsepower already offers better fuel consumption than the hybrid products in the same segment from Mercedes, BMW and Lexus," he says. "So if we now introduce our clean diesel technology on that car, imagine where it goes."

What's more, diesel engines deliver better performance than hybrid technology, especially when it comes to torque.

Toyota Prius VToyota Prius VOf course, economy isn't everything (and besides that, you can't argue with the fact that more than half of the vehicles on this list are hybrids). The little stuff matters, too, because it adds up quickly over time: According to government data, more than 42 million Americans spend at least 30 minutes in the car on their morning commute. Seven million spend more than an hour.

The bottom line? Be honest about the particularities of your own commute and diligent enough to research which vehicle best fits that lifestyle. At the very least you'll need something spacious enough for comfort, efficient enough for decent gas mileage and durable enough to withstand the inevitable fender-bender. And you won't be alone.

Here are the nine cars (in no particular order):

1. Ford Fusion Hybrid
MSRP: $28,700

2. Toyota Highlander Hybrid
MSRP: $38,540

3. Lexus CT 200h
MSRP:
$29,120

4. Scion xD
MSRP:
$16,075

5. Chevrolet Volt
MSRP:
$39,145

6. Honda Fit
MSRP: $15,175

7. Toyota Prius V
MSRP:
$26,400

8. Subaru Forester
MSRP: $20,595

9. Toyota RAV4
MSRP: $22,475


Full List: The Best Cars For Commuters 2012

 
  • James  •  Tampa, Florida  •  2 months ago
    Has everyone ignored that a significant amount of oil is used to generate electricity ? The same electricity that goes into the batteries of the cars to charge them up ? I've visited a power plant that had railroad tankercars full of oil lined up to be burnt. I don't know how it can be more efficient when it burns to boil water to create steam to run turbines to generate electricity and then through powerlines to plug in to charge up the batteries to make the car go.
  • pH  •  Mt Hamilton, California  •  3 months ago
    Best car for communters opens with a $100K tesla? I didn't even bother with the rest of the article, what an IDIOT. Write two articles if you love the tesla, a car you will likely never see let alone own.
    • sodagrrl 3 months ago
      You are so right. For $100k I'd hire someone to drive me back and forth to work.
    • Trice 3 months ago
      For 100K It better drive itself
    • Poopdaddy 3 months ago
      I have seen many they have a show room at the mall in Higlands Ranch.
  • Aaron  •  3 months ago
    The old Ford 300 engine could easily last 300,000 miles before you need to do an over haul. BRING BACK LONG LASTING ENGINES. Not only long lasting but ones where the average person can work on it in their own garage.
    • brian swells 3 months ago
      they wont briing it back its all about money now
    • fleabag 3 months ago
      Ford will rust in hell
  • Gavin  •  Reno, Nevada  •  3 months ago
    Best Cars period is the one you want to drive not a beer can with a battery,
    my personal favorite 06 GTO 17-25mpg, 96 Ford bronco 14-18mpg, 91 Jeep Grand wagooneer 11-13mg. Point is Im faster I wont get stuck in the mud or snow, and wont die in my ride when you are in your beer can not paying attention texting on your Iphone. what good is gas mileage if you can't put your ski's,bikes, golf clubs, family, and ride in comfort. Plus hybrid batteries are not cheap $5000 and up every 5 year or so.
  • Lt Keefer  •  Austin, Texas  •  3 months ago
    The author of this story is a moron. Commuters want high mpg as well as some level of comfort and safety. There are a lot of other cars on the road that get better mileage and have decent rides than anything on this list.
    • Edward 3 months ago
      have you actually driven a volt? its comparable to an audi a4.... my friend that owns the A4 agrees with me....
    • Lloyd 3 months ago
      VW TDI 42 to 46 MPG, no matter how you drive it.
    • No One 3 months ago
      The Volt is a joke.
  • Steven  •  Tampa, Florida  •  3 months ago
    My late model hybrid broke down on me twice on the highway with battery issues. I'll pay a little more for gas and arrive safely with my family.
    • Michael 3 months ago
      That is what I'm afraid of.
    • Jacque D 3 months ago
      And your sure a non-hybrid isn't ever going to break down? Anything with moving parts can break regardless of it's chosen fuel source.
    • Steven 3 months ago
      I've owned many cars in my life. This was a new hybrid that left me stranded twice on business trips, far from home. Sorry, but that just hasn't happened to me with a non-hybrid vehicle, especially not in a new car.
  • Rob  •  Elmhurst, Illinois  •  3 months ago
    why the hell is any SUV on a commuter car list? The best commuter car would be a non hybrid base model sub-compact. You don't have to be an economics major to realize that buying a $15,000 Yaris makes more sense than a $23,000 Prius. How many tanks of gas does an $8,000 price premium get you? If you drove 30,000 miles in a year like I do then the Prius would take over 6 years to break even, probably around the time you will need to replace the $4,000 battery in the Prius.
    • MK 3 months ago
      Let's see, $15K Yaris at 38 mpg for 250,000 miles x $4 per gal = $26315 fuel cost. -- Total ($15000+$26315)/250000 =$0.21 per mile

      $23000 Prius at 48 mpg for 250,000 miles x $4 per gal = $20833 fuel cost, plus replace a $4K battery twice. -- Total ($23000+$20833+$8000)/250000 = $0.21 per mile.

      Feel free to tweak my numbers.
    • Mr. D. 3 months ago
      The base model Civic get's almost the same mileage as the same model as a hybrid! All this "green" stuff is a ripoff, it's all too expensive for most people as it is,and it doesn't even meet it's projected fuel savings! If Obama wants to really see average fuel economy nearly double, he could begin allowing car companies to import the diesel engines that the rest of the world gets. Otherwise he's simply talking out of his butt,which all of the politicians do anyway.
    • Melea 3 months ago
      I've had a Yaris for three and a half years and drive 42 miles each way to work. I actually average 40 mpg and have gotten as high as 46 on the interstate. I'm right at 100,000 miles and have had no maintenance costs except for oil changes and an air filter. You can't beat those numbers.
  • Keith  •  Spokane, Washington  •  3 months ago
    It's not the mpg that counts the most. it's what you pay for it and how long it lasts. The most economical car I ever had was a 1978 Cadillac Fleetwood. I bought it used with 6,600 miles on it for about $5,800.00 and used it with std, maintainance, little repair and I kept it till it had 780,000 miles on it. I sold it to a neighbor for $400.00 and he moved to Kansas and last I heard it had another 40,000 miles on it . That good value for the buck. Too bad GM doesn't build cars like that today.
  • Paul  •  3 months ago
    How many miles do you have to drive before your reach your break-even point for a $39k Volt?
  • Fox  •  3 months ago
    Dont buy the big V8 then cry about the gas mileage .
  • Jerry  •  3 months ago
    I live in northern North Dakota, I would like to see how far a electric car goes at 30 below 0. I would like to see what speed you could get out of it at that temperature and how it maintains its speed, when the battery starts getting weaker.I would also like to know about the heater at that temperature. I dont think it will work very well in the northern states
  • Randy  •  Colorado Springs, Colorado  •  3 months ago
    why are these articles ALWAYS about new cars? I can name a handful of "older" vehicles that are more reliable, get just as good gas mileage, and cost much MUCH less
  • Billy Bob Robert  •  3 months ago
    They could have just said buy a hybrid. Would have saved a whole page.
  • KEITH  •  Lexington, Kentucky  •  3 months ago
    Volkswagon Jetta TDI (diesel) should be at the top of the list, not some POS hybrid.
    My 04 gets 40mpg around town and 48mpg on the highway. Paid 14k for it 5yrs ago w/30k miles on it and the KBB value is still around 10k. Best car I've ever owned,....hands down.
  • Mel  •  3 months ago
    Best car for commuters in todays economy....anything that moves safely, and is cheap on gas.....Cars cost as much today as a house did in the early 80's...Unless your rich or plan to live in your car. Cheap is the new commuter car...
  • Josh  •  3 months ago
    A hybrid SUV pushing 40K is 2nd on this list and no mid 20K TDI is mentioned?
  • John  •  Elmhurst, Illinois  •  3 months ago
    We......................can put a man on the moon............but can only come up with a 60 mile per charge battery??????????? Come on! I don't believe that! They're gonna have to come up with ALOT better ideas with the cars to get me interrested!
  • Midwest Voter  •  Geneva, Ohio  •  3 months ago
    Any information from Forbes is useless and biased. Why does Yahoo allow this garbage?
  • Rob  •  Elmhurst, Illinois  •  3 months ago
    Yea a chevy volt, I drive 80 miles round trip so 20 of that would be on battery.
  • Torrent  •  3 months ago
    You could always find a broken down KIA on the side of a highway for free.

Top Rated

Category: Sedans

RESEARCH A CAR