Search

Driving green means not changing your oil until you need to

When was the last time state tax dollars went toward telling you not to do something?

Ads against drunk driving, certainly. Perhaps ads against smoking cigarettes.

But now, California is embarking on a campaign to persuade its citizens not to change their oil so much.

More modern motor oils, better control of the combustion process through vastly more powerful electronic circuitry, and the persistence of generations-old auto advice have combined to lengthen oil-change intervals.

Yet many of us change our oil more often than we need to.

In California, in fact, roughly half of all drivers change their oil every 3,000 miles—or even more often!—despite manufacturers' recommended intervals for new cars that may be a multiple of that number.

And that, says California's Department of Resources, Recycling and Recovery, wastes oil that could potentially have a far longer life.

According to a story in the Los Angeles Times, the department has launched an ad campaign to encourage owners to be aware of the recommended oil-change interval for their car.

The tagline "Check Your Number," is also the domain name for a website that links owners to a website that gives the the carmaker's recommended interval—these days, often 7,500 to 15,000 miles—for their specific vehicle.

That links to some general advice about what the number means, along descriptions of unusual driving patterns that might require more frequent oil changes. Other more standard advice: Keep your tires properly inflated and switch off the engine if the car is stopped for more than a few seconds.

If every driver moved to the recommended oil-change interval, says a department spokesman, 10 million gallons of engine oil could be saved each year.

The change might as much as halve the amount of money drivers spend on oil changes, which cost $25 and up at quick-change facilities and potentially more at dealerships.

While green concerns aren't necessarily top of mind for many car owners, even in California, the economic argument will likely resonate with lots of people feeling the pinch of the three-year-old recession.

In other words, it's a win-win situation: Driving green means only replacing your engine oil when you really need to, and that saves you money.

Even the shrillest talk-radio hosts may find it hard to fight that one—though we have a sneaking suspicion they'll try anyway.

 
  • dontlikeitgetoverit  •  9 days ago
    Yeah, sorry I'd rather change my oil on time to avoid issues in the long run and waste more money in the long run...
  • Mitch Shaw  •  Atlanta, Georgia  •  10 days ago
    Auto manufacturers are in the business to sell cars. I am in the business of repairing cars. I have noticed in the almost 30 yrs I have been doing it that several things have occurred: (a) yes, oil qualities have changed to the point where going from 3k to maybe 15k would probably be just fine, if all we were concerned with was the oil - but there are numerous other factors, (b) engines have changed from being primarily steel to aluminum, and even plastic in some cases, for internal components, meaning that having good, clean high flowing oil is more important than ever, (c) aluminum and plastic create more particles in the oil as they sheer and wear easier than did the steel, and the oil carries these particles to the filter, as its design intent, (d) oil also acts as a secondary engine cooler to the antifreeze - oil with high particle counts and low flow does not cool as well as clean, high flowing oils, (e) oil passages in engines have been reduced in their diameter, which also leads to the need for oils which are clean and high flowing - it also raises oil pressures, and, (f) oil filters haven't really changed in the slightest.

    Summarily, there are always those out there with the 300k engines that only changed their oil every 20k; those are the exceptions. It is far more likely that one will experience catastrophic engine failure by 100-125k on such a program. I do my best to extend the life of my customer's vehicles because if they get a new one, it has a warranty, and I lose their repair business for at least three years. Therefore, by having them engage in an aggressive and comprehensive maintenance program, which includes oil and filter changes at 4 mo/5k mi, we extend their engine life. We do take advantage of the engineering advances in auto parts, but we don't buy into the manufacturer's marketing nonsense - also called planned obsolescence. This is a program in which the manufacturer determines the balance at which they can let the car fail, but yet still retain enough customers to keep the company viable - the car's failure is engineered into the vehicle; they know and can predict each parts' failure within a few months or a few thousand miles. If nothing fails, they do not sell parts or cars, and they go under; think about it.

    So, do you want to be "green", and spend thousands of dollars repairing and replacing your second most valuable investment - unnecessarily? Or, do you want to follow the sane advice of an ASE certified Master Tech of almost 30 yrs experience, with nothing to gain unless your car keeps going down the road? Which makes more sense?
    • WAdE 10 days ago
      Sooo what are you saying? Because you say the oil oil quality is good enough now a days to go 15k miles, but then talk about todays crappy engines and how if the oil isn't free flowing and free of dirts/sediments. So In one sentence what are you trying to say? Lol 3k miles or 15k
    • George 10 days ago
      5,000 miles "MAX."!!--UNLESS YOU USE THE GOOD STUFF--"MOBIL ONE" ECT.
  • Dollah Dave  •  10 days ago
    3000 miles?Lay off the damn drugs,will 'ya! LOL
  • Burn your credit card  •  Dallas, Texas  •  11 days ago
    My 1985(!) Fiero V6 said 7500 miles for normal duty. I thought that was a bit long, but this is nothing new.
  • frankly speaking  •  10 days ago
    Here's a thought: by changing the oil at regular, sensible intervals, (before a large volume of it gets burned past the pistons and rings or evap vacuum) you not only reduce wear on the internal engine components, but more of the total amount of oil you put into the engine gets drained out - and is able to be recycled!
    Gasoline and disel fuel is non-renewable - lubricating oil is.
  • Freedom4all  •  10 days ago
    I wouldn't go 15k on regular oil. Use a synthetic for any interval over 7500 miles. the non-synthetic evaporates leaving a sludge build-up over time.
  • steve  •  Oklahoma City, Oklahoma  •  10 days ago
    yea and some nasty ass's change there drawers every month!
  • Pilgrim  •  11 days ago
    The oil in my engine is cleaner than when it came out of the bottle.

    30 years ago I bought an oil filter for $300 that takes out dirt the size of cigarette smoke particles. It also removes water from the oil, so sludge and acid never form.

    And I never change oil. I just add a quart once a month when I change the filter medium which costs about a buck.

    This engine has 300,000 miles on it and it's still going strong. It's coming up on a valve job, but I'm hoping to get 500,000 out of the lower end.

    I told one lie. When I bought the filter, it costed $27. Today they cost $300.
    • oldieswmrk 11 days ago
      Where do you get this filter? Are they available for all cars?
    • Robert 10 days ago
      Common sense tells you that changing oil more often can't possibly wear anything out. Car manufacturers are in the business of selling cars, do you think that they will tell you to change your oil more often??? Changing oil at 5,000 to higher miles than that is just plain stupidity!!!! Its the life blood of your engine, think about it. By the way, what shape is California in, they can't even give the money they collect for state taxes back to their residents at the end of the year that they owe them.
    • Don 10 days ago
      Knowledge trumps fear every time. Why wait for 3000 miles why not 1500? You could make the same arguement. 7500 miles is the new "3000 miles".
  • John  •  Albany, New York  •  11 days ago
    toyota had recommendations for changing oil every 7,500 miles and there came reports of oil sludging and caused a flurry of blogging. Toyota blamed owners for neglecting their car maintenance. Finally toyota finally backed up their product and replaced engines on cars with first owners according to a certain criterion. Oil breaks down due to acid, water in oil ( due to short trips), and certain driving conditions. Owners manuals tell you to change oil due to severe driving condition ( are they ever really explained to the owners?) Valvoline tell me to change my oil every 4,000 miles for maximum engine protection ( according to their engine guarantee). So since driving conditions deem the time intervals how are owners supposed to guage the proper time to change it. Or should this Gov't program implement this at a time where California economy is in dissaray. There seems to be a lack of sense to where the priorities when it comes to economics when it comes to priorities. Or does the green movement take presidence over everything?
  • CMax  •  10 days ago
    As a retired oil sales rep I can tell you old habits are hard to break. If you are ever lucky enough to visit an oil packaging company where they blend, color, package and label, oils for many different brands it is really an eye opener. Lined up outside at the loading docks are, Shell, Texaco, Fina, Mobil, Exxon, as well as others. Not a lot of difference in any motor oil. The oil comes in on a tanker from Texas then is pumped inside to be mixed, "colored", (remember Sears Golden?) canned, bottled, labeled, and then loaded on semi trailers. Would television commercials lie to you? You bet.
  • david  •  Los Angeles, California  •  11 days ago
    oil's cheaper than a new engine, and easier to get
  • AtomicRooster  •  10 days ago
    This is total horseshit here. I change my oil and filter every 2000 miles on all my cars and I stand firm on that platform. I am religious about it. I've never sold a car to anyone that was an oil burner either. And most cars I have sold at that point had well over 250,000 miles on them. Keeping the oil clean is the life blood of any engine. Oil changes are cheaper than engine rebuilds. Priced a rebuilt motor lately?
    • Crystal 10 days ago
      You're dead on! My Dad, who is a third generation Auto mechanic, changes his religiously every 2,000 miles, as well. He said there's only so much mud in a gallon of mud, and once the viscosity breaks down, oil doesn't lubricate anymore. You can take the manufacturer's word for it, if you will, but remember, they're in the business to sell new cars and new parts. So if you wipe out your engine, then you get to make a choice: New engine or new car. And either way, it's profitable. Especially on these new technologies that are out there. Can't imagine what a new engine for a Prius would run...Make your choice, though. You can listen to the guys in the business of selling new stuff, or you can listen to the ones in the business of keeping them on the road and running. Perhaps if California spent half as much time getting rid of excessive regulations that strangle business in that state as they do in worrying about the "green initiative", they'd have a budget surplus instead of a massive shortfall.
  • Jerry  •  El Cajon, California  •  10 days ago
    You can change your oil every 5000 to 7500 miles and at 100000 you will buy a new car. That is what the manufacture wants you to do. If you change it every 3 to 4000 miles you can drive that car until it has well over 250000 miles on it.
    Go ahead and wait I change mine every 3000 and have 170000 on it now. it still runs like new and I reccommend it to my friends.
    I am a Tech for GM
  • .  •  St James, New York  •  11 days ago
    This is a huge con job by the state not too mention the car manufactures love the fact you will buy a car more often since you are not changing you oil enough to safeguard your engine. Plus the report says nothing about the various driving patterns and traffic inqured that dramilcally alters the life cycle of the oil. WHAT A SCAM SO YOU BUY ANOTHER CAR QUICKER. WE ALL KNOW HOW THEIR BUSINESS IS DOWN.
    • Don 10 days ago
      Chrysler just posted it's best sales quarter in 14 years. All new car sales are up. The oil companies are selling the con! WAKE UP !!!
    • dontlikeitgetoverit 9 days ago
      agreed!
  • Richard Mccomic  •  Phoenix, Arizona  •  10 days ago
    Am I missing a point on this "Oil-Change" subject? The computer tells us when oil
    change is needed! That takes guessing out of the equation?
    HAPPY MOTHER'SA DAY TO ALL THE MOMS, MAY GOD BLESS YOU ALWAYS!!!
  • MIKE,STEVE  •  9 days ago
    pay me now or pay me later
  • MIKE,STEVE  •  9 days ago
    don't ya just love how politicians get into every thing.
    now thier in the oil change business
  • Don  •  Florence, South Carolina  •  10 days ago
    The 3000 mile oil change myth has been perpetuated by three industries. The oil manufactures, the filter manufacturers and quick lube facilities. It makes more sense that longer oil change intervals would adversely their income. I've been in the auto parts business with ASE certification for over thirty years. The 3000 mile oil change was the "rule" then and still people fall for it today. Isn't it counter intuitive to think that their has been no improvement in oil, filter, and engine manufacturing techniques in all those years? Oil today is so much higher quality than even 10 years ago. Just look at the API ratings on the bottle. As far as certain cars having sludge issues, this is all due to poor engine design. That certain Toyota engine had to have the oil changed more frequently to compensate for a poorly designed lubrication system. Durability is a product of design. Honda uses the same metals in their 2.2L Accord engine as GM uses in it's 2.2L engine, but Honda consistently lasts three times as long. Has nothing to do with changing the oil. It's better design.
    As far as selling more new cars, new , innovative, cool looking cars works much better than how long the engine lasts. The majority of owners barely keep a care more than 5 years, most manufactures warranty the drivetrain for that time. So it's the second or third owner that looks at longevity. So do yourself and your environment a favor and change your oil as recommended by the people that designed and built your car. Don't be a corporate sheep and waste money because of a myth perpetuated by the oil change industry.
  • MIKE,STEVE  •  9 days ago
    synthetic oil doesn't break down like like regular motor oil once did......
    but, contaminants that wear on your engine still appear.
  • Cw  •  Baltimore, Maryland  •  11 days ago
    Ford and conoco's research has shown that changing motor oil too often causes more engine wear.
    • Thor's Hammer 10 days ago
      Bull Shit.
    • Broken 10 days ago
      There is a balance for everything in life. Go synthetic and every 5000
    • TerryM 9 days ago
      BS

Follow Yahoo! Autos

RESEARCH A CAR

Top Rated

Category: Sedans

More Articles

  • Most improved cars 2012 Marco R. della Cava

    Total Car Score recently released a list of Most Improved Cars for 2012, highlighting eight redesigned automobiles whose improvements helped the models’ scores jump significantly over 2011.

  • Memorial Day means many things to Americans: An opportunity to remember those who've died in service of their country. A chance to get together with friends and relatives. Cookouts. Picnics. Box socials. (They still have those, right?)

  • Take one look at these purpose-built sports cars and you'd expect them to be fast. You would be wrong. Even before we got used to powerful V6 Camrys, these ten rides chosen by Jalopnik readers were the slowest sports cars the world had ever seen.

  • "High performance" and "fuel efficient" need not be mutually exclusive terms, thanks to some truly quick cars that get surprisingly respectable mileage.

  • One of the most widely accepted bits of advice you’ll find presented in practically every consumer magazine as Wisdom From Upon High is a bad idea.