Search

Used Car Buying Mistakes That Cost You Money


MORE AT USNEWS.COM

When you’re shopping for a used car, one mistake can cost you. Buying a vehicle that needs expensive repairs and not negotiating can mean the difference between saving money and spending more than you’d like. After reaching record highs, used car prices are starting to fall, so if you must buy now, avoid these common used car buying mistakes that translate into dollars.

Not knowing a vehicle’s history

Hugo90/flickrHugo90/flickrWhen you buy a used car, you don’t know how well it was maintained. CarFax and AutoCheck provide vehicle history reports which tell you if the car was in an accident, if it’s been rebuilt, who owned it and lists its service, inspection and registration history. 

After you get the vehicle’s records, have an independent mechanic perform a pre-purchase inspection. For about $75 to $150, the mechanic will be able to tell you if the car has any major mechanical problems or will need expensive repairs. If a private seller won’t let you have the car inspected, this is usually a red flag that something is wrong.

David Hays, a 25-year automotive industry veteran and former owner of Wrenchmasters in Rockville, Md., says that even if you aren’t a mechanic, you can inspect the car yourself, and there are specific things you should look for.

“On the exterior, look for oil or other fluid leaks under the car, odd wear or worn-out tires and new or different paint,” Hays says. “A car that has been painted indicates crash damage and is a red flag. Crash damage can be extensive or minor but always affects the value negatively. Look for ‘orange peel’ paint on body panels, paint fading at different rates on different parts of the car, irregular gaps in between body panels and overspray on weather seals.”

Pop the hood and look for cracks on the back of drive belts, excessive black crud under the oil fill cap, which indicates a lack of oil changes, and stickers under the hood, Hays says. If there aren’t any stickers, the hood panel may have been replaced, a red flag that the vehicle was in an accident.

“During the test drive, listen to the exhaust,” Hays says. “Does it sound normal and not overly loud? Make sure the blower (fan) works, and the power windows and locks are functional. Check to see if engine lights or other dash lights are on. On a level road, does the car track straight if you were to remove your hands from the steering wheel? Does the car drive to one side or does the brake pedal pulsate when braking?”

Not negotiating the price

“A consumer’s best weapon in the dealership is their feet,” says Jack Nerad, executive market analyst at Kelley Blue Book. “They can walk out at any time and they’ll probably find as good as or better deal the next day or week.”

It’s easy to get excited about buying a car, but it’s best to take some time and think about the purchase.

“There are tons of used cars out there for sale,” Nerad says. “Finding a good used car is not like finding a diamond at the bottom of a mud puddle.”

Since used car values are up almost 20 percent since January, according to KBB.com, Nerad suggests comparing used and new vehicle prices. You may be able to get a new vehicle at a comparable price and eliminate the worries associated with vehicle condition.

“This is one of the few times where a new vehicle is almost as good a buy as a late-model used vehicle,” he explains. “Buy as new a car as you can comfortably afford because a newer car has better resale value.”

Not negotiating the price of your trade-in


Because used car prices are at their highest levels in years, you can easily command more money for your trade-in, especially if it is fuel-efficient. The National Automobile Dealers Association said in May that trade-in values of small cars would increase more than 30 percent in June. First, look up the value of your trade online. Then shop your used car around to local dealerships to see what they’ll offer you. Also look online to see what similar cars are selling for in your area for a better idea of your trade-in’s market value.

Not negotiating the financing

Nerad says that when many shoppers finance a used car, they don’t shop around. He suggests going to your credit union or bank to get a pre-approved rate before applying through the dealership.

Shoppers should realize they can make counter offers on the interest rate the dealer offers them, he explains.

As you cross-shop financing, don’t focus on monthly payments, which is a common mistake shoppers make, Nerad says. “Dealers can lower the monthly payment by a considerable margin by lengthening the loan term,” he explains. The longer the term, the more interest you’ll pay, so run the numbers and research all your financing options.

Not researching add-ons and extended warranties

Many dealers will offer you add-ons, like paint and upholstery protection, VIN etching and an extended warranty.

Nerad says that add-ons are negotiable and with a little online research, shoppers can get an approximate price range of what these features would cost if they purchased them aftermarket.

Deciding whether or not to purchase an extended warranty depends on your “tolerance for risk,” Nerad explains. The extended warranty is really more like an insurance policy that will protect you from “catastrophic problems, like the engine falling apart or the transmission breaking down,” he says. Small repairs are generally not covered.

“Ask to look at the warranty coverage,” Nerad says. As long as you understand what is covered, purchasing an extended warranty might make sense. “If you have tolerance for risk and you feel comfortable about the car you bought, then you probably don’t need the extended warranty,” he adds.
 

265 comments

  • Scott  •  10 months ago
    Car Fax, Auto check? Don't count on that info 100% They can only report what has been reported to Ins Co. and other entities. People fix cars Every day on a customer pay basis and do Not tell Ins about the accident for a number of reasons. I see it every day, buyer be ware. Have the car inspected by someone who not only knows mechanical info but also auto body.
    • Santiago 10 months ago
      Not only that but if the car is an out of state car, once it gets registered in the current state, often times the history will not transfer over, meaning you could have a car with Frame damage, and it had been in a previous accident before. and still have a clean car fax.
    • Richard 10 months ago
      Unless someone is injured, I NEVER contact the police or the insurance company after an accident. If it's my fault I pay it out of pocket. If the other person's fault, I let them pay it out of pocket if they want to and can.
    • J 10 months ago
      Carfax and Auto Check are only a consumer pacifier. They give people the false impression that they cover everything and their word is golden. NOT TRUE. They can only report whats been reported to them that's it. False sense of security for the consumer and Carfax has been WAY WRONG several times in my past experiences.
  • .  •  10 months ago
    I saved a ton on buying a new/used car by keeping my old one. True story.
    • Monte 10 months ago
      "I saved a ton on buying a new/used car by keeping my old one."? WTF does that mean? I have sold cars for 10 years, I have been driving for 31 years. I have owned 37 cars, trucks, vans and motorcycles. You have no idea what you are talking about. Yes, you can save some money if you sell you own vehicle. How much more are you paying in taxes due to the credit you get for trading in your old vehicle? How many people do you have to take on test drives? How many people do you have that offer you 1/3 of what you are asking for the car? When I listen to people like you talk about buying a car and keeping the old one, all I hear is "Wah Wah Wah Wah Wah Wah Wah!" You sound like Charlie Brown's teacher.
    • Mr Magoo 10 months ago
      Monte, you sound like a hostile car dealer. We have hung onto our cars until they died (drove a Chrysler minivan until it had 300,000 miles on it -- lasted us 14 yrs) and we have saved a ton of money. Regarding repair bills, if you get an HONEST mechanic that will charge you an honest rate and NOT sell you crap LIKE WATER PUMPS that are not needed, it's your best bet and never buy a car from a hot head sales person. If you've owned 37 vehicles you're buying junk I guess that doesn't hold up. Sorry for your loss big guy.
    • Matthew 10 months ago
      lol If my old cars last that long. lol my last car engine went tranny went and needed whole new exhaust. NOT me a nice G6 for a steal. I know how to buy a car. Get the biggest prick you know. My case got my dad. He walked out like 3 times and saved me about 3,200 dollars. true story.
  • DENNIS  •  10 months ago
    I have a tip for buying a car....DON'T FINANCE
    • Confused 10 months ago
      Hmmmm 95 percent of Americans dont have more than 2000 dollars in their account...hmmm average used car cost $10-15k go figure..lucky you that you have sooo much money saved
    • ArmidilloJoe 10 months ago
      As soon as you buy your car start putting money away for the next one, you are making your car payments to yourself and earning interest on the money while you save. Once you have the money saved up and need the next car you can pay cash and save a bundle in interest to the bank. Then repeat the process, the hard part is saving the money the first time, after that just concider your monthly payment to your savings as your car payment...
    • Mr Magoo 10 months ago
      Am 65 yrs old and have NEVER financed a car.
  • jonathan  •  10 months ago
    “This is one of the few times where a new vehicle is almost as good a buy as a late-model used vehicle,” he explains. “Buy as new a car as you can comfortably afford because a newer car has better resale value.”
    This makes no sense. A newer car has a better resale while its is newer, but the value drops quicker than an older car. If you buy an older car the value lost is a lower percentage. Buy a 2009 car for 20k in five years it will be worth around 10k. Buy a 2004 car for 10k and it will be worth 7k in five years.
    • A Yahoo! User 10 months ago
      Or in my case, buy a 1994 toyota Camry with a "blown engine" and lowish miles for $400. Replace the timing belt and water pump at a cost of $240, and then immediately resell the car for $2300. Repeat a few times, and you've got money for a new car.
    • drwings 10 months ago
      What kind of 12 year old car is worth $7000?
    • David Weber 10 months ago
      A lot actually. You would be surprised. Fuel efficiency is getting very important.
  • paul r  •  10 months ago
    its funny how people are rushing to say get it checked out by a good mechanic, but in another post which talks about mechanics they will be the first to bash them. make up your mind.
    • A Yahoo! User 10 months ago
      The key is finding an honest mechanic. It is possible. We have a friend who started his own business as a mechanic. We go to him for everything now.
  • Jason  •  10 months ago
    Why not just keep the car you have and put some money into it? It's still a lot cheaper than buying a used car.
  • Nick  •  10 months ago
    Ive been ripped off by big-name car dealerships and dishonest people from Craigslist, etc, so I tried something new the last time I needed to buy a used truck...I went to a small and likely unknown dealer. Many times, you can deal with the owner of one of these places directly and they will be more honest with you about the vehicle you are about to buy. I bought my truck and my wife's truck from a small dealership. I feel I got a good deal on both vehicles, and the dealer was patient, not pushy, let me take a test drive...alone..., and answered ALL my questions prior to my handing over any money. The weren't afraid to show me the problems with the vehicle, either, so I had a better idea of what I was getting into. I've never had any major problems with either truck, even years after buying them. As opposed to a Cadillac I bought from a big-name dealer that had a blown head gasket and a transmission that gave out a year later... And a used Chevy Blazer I bought off Craigslist which had major engine problems even after the seller swore it was in tip-top mechanical shape...
  • Jimmy  •  10 months ago
    every car dealership (new or used) always has the salesguys standing around like vultures waiting to pounce on the next living thing that walks by or in!! horrible it keeps me away
  • Carolyn  •  10 months ago
    I purchased a car (2yrs ago) from a car dealership, got the car Fax report after 4 request for it at that time. Wanted to trad it in, had another car dealership do a Auto Check and we found out this car has uni-body damage. Now the car dealership that sold it to me did not disclose this information to us at the time of purchase but, I know they knew, because it's in the Auto Check report that it was announced at the auction that they bought it from., what can I do?Help!
  • Stevo  •  10 months ago
    this is the worst advice ever!!!!. i work at a car dealership and just because a car is painted does not mean its been in a crash. we paint cars if they have heavy scratched or if there is a dent. also we do not move on our prices, i dont care if you walk out. we sell everything fro cheap and way below everyone else. and again we dont budge on trade prices because we do not have profit in our cars like other dealerships have.on the topic of financing. you cant chew down rates if its not in house or at a big dealer. we dont give the rate the bank does. if you want a lower rate pay your bills and dont be a loser.rant off...
  • DW  •  10 months ago
    I bought a used Chevrolet Avalanche from Crystal automotive in Crystal River Fl and did not buy an extended warranty because the previous vehicle I purchased from them never had any problems. Boy was I wrong. Over a 6 moth period I spent over $4,000 in repairs and Crystal Automotive never offered to cover any of the expenses. Unfortunately I did not do my homework and learned a valuable lesson so if your going to buy a used vehicle make sure you have it checked out but more importantly DO NOT go to Crystal Automotive in Crystal River FL.
  • Kristi  •  10 months ago
    We had car auction roll in to town for awhile. I live south of Los Angeles. I purchased a car after having a mechanic friend check it out. The following day a lot of smoke was coming from the bottom of the car. I had purchased some warranty that they offered where they pay the first $300 and I pay the rest (their mechanic). They told me there was an $800 repair needed. I got a 2nd opinion (thank goodness). My mechanic found a 4" x 6" piece of thick tape stuck onto my exhaust pipe. He simply removed the tape, the smoking stopped, and I saved $500.
  • Scott P  •  10 months ago
    Having 14 years dealership experience, be careful, the salesman is not your friend. They will always try to sell you the vehicle they can make the most profit on,or one they have had the longest. Be careful and do your research. The best way to tell when a salesman is lying, his lips are moving.
  • Schwarzkopf Reagan  •  10 months ago
    Just because a car has been in an accident doesn't mean it is a bad car. Almost every car I've owned was wrecked when I got it. If the person fixing it does a good job it is just as good as when it left the manufacturer. Also, if the car was wrecked and it wasn't turned into the insurance company it won't turn up on any vehicle report.
  • little john  •  10 months ago
    seen a used car that interested mewith a price tag of $14,500. when i sat down with the salesman he wrote up the sales order with the price for the car at $17,500. I showed him the sales tag that was on the car and he then said I have to check with my manager. I caught him in trying to up the price and could not get out of it, since I told him I would walk!
    He apolgized and wrote up a correct sales contract and told him I will get my financing elsewhere. Boy, ya gotta what these carsalesmen or women like a hawk otherwise your screwed royally!! Buyer beware!!
  • rocketman350  •  10 months ago
    buy cars from older people. younger folks beat the crap out of a car and pay little attention to that strange sound coming from under the hood... probably because the music is too loud
  • red  •  10 months ago
    If you are planning to buy a used car do a online search for -dealer scams-.
    You'll find many web sites that give info on all the tricks that dealers use {new or used} on the custumers.
  • Monte  •  10 months ago
    I've been driving for 31 years. I've owned 37 cars, trucks, vans and motorcycles. I sold cars for 10 years. I was a Finance Manager at a local dealership. My record month, I sold 23 cars, trucks and vans during a month with 20 working days.

    The fact of the matter is, you need to find a salesperson you can trust, a dealer that has a good reputation, a vehicle brand you feel is dependable and stick with them. Building a relationship with your salesperson is just as important as your relationship with your Family Doctor, your kids teacher, your financial advisor, etc. Most people just go with the first salesperson that comes out of the door at the dealership. Do you think you can develop good rapport with someone in 30 min.? Do you think he really cares about you? I'll answer that. NO! All he wants to do is sell you a car. That's what he gets paid for. Go to the car salesman that goes to your church, the one that has a kid on your kids little league team, the one you chat with when you eat breakfast at the local coffee clatch hang out. Good car sales people are always looking for ways to meet people and build relationships. That's the one that will steer you away from the pile of junk that looks nice but under the skin it's junk.

    As far as the advise about negotiation the price and the price of the trade in. That information is getting old. Many dealerships do not negotiate the price of the car or the trade anymore. If they are a true "Best Price" dealership, they won't negotiate the price of the car in any way. They may offer you several finance options, but that isn't really in their control. The banks determine, based on your credit score, what you will pay for intrest rates and how long of a term you can have.
  • Shawn R  •  10 months ago
    As a used car salesman, I find it extremely disturbing that we are all lumped into one huddled mass of lying, deceitful people for trying to make an honest living. I am sorry if you have had some negative experiences with someless that honest dealers, but we are all not alike These are large ticket items and everyone wants to get the best deal possible, but we are in busines to make money, not a charity. If we sold eveything to everyone at cost, youd have nowhere to go to get a used vehicle, right? One last thing, the percentage of profit made on a used vehicle is extremely low in comparison to our normal everyday items you buy, but no public outrage to that??
  • A Yahoo! User  •  10 months ago
    Negotiation is the key when buying used or new vehicle. Do research on the vehicle you want. Go to the dealership and make a low offer for the vehicle. If the sticker price is $30,000 make a low offer of $22,000 and ask for a year free of oil change, tire rotation and alignment. Also negotiate your financing. You can get good rates if you have good credit score. Good negotiation skills will save you money. After agreeing on the price, make sure not to buy extended warranty or any add-on services. Know your limit and don’t buy something you can’t afford.

Follow Yahoo! Autos

RESEARCH A CAR

Top Rated

Category: Sedans

More Articles

  • Most improved cars 2012 Marco R. della Cava

    Total Car Score recently released a list of Most Improved Cars for 2012, highlighting eight redesigned automobiles whose improvements helped the models’ scores jump significantly over 2011.

  • Memorial Day means many things to Americans: An opportunity to remember those who've died in service of their country. A chance to get together with friends and relatives. Cookouts. Picnics. Box socials. (They still have those, right?)

  • Take one look at these purpose-built sports cars and you'd expect them to be fast. You would be wrong. Even before we got used to powerful V6 Camrys, these ten rides chosen by Jalopnik readers were the slowest sports cars the world had ever seen.

  • "High performance" and "fuel efficient" need not be mutually exclusive terms, thanks to some truly quick cars that get surprisingly respectable mileage.

  • One of the most widely accepted bits of advice you’ll find presented in practically every consumer magazine as Wisdom From Upon High is a bad idea.