2019 Toyota Yaris vs. 2020 Nissan Versa in Photos

The Yaris sedan is a long-time favorite around C/D HQ and we've included it in our annual Editor's Choice list, thanks to its spunky driving demeanor and overall value.

Historically speaking, the Nissan Versa has been somewhat of an also-ran in the small-car segment, choosing to go after the title of cheapest new car in America rather than excelling at, you know, actually being a solid car. But, the Versa is all-new for 2020 and it is significantly improved.

Despite the Versa's freshness, the Yaris offers the best experience for drivers who care about driving. Its steering is well-weighted and direct, which helps give the Yaris an agile, tossable feel that encourages back-road fun.

The Versa, while much more competent than its predecessor, simply is less rewarding to pilot than the Yaris, coming off as a more relaxed conveyance with a cushy ride, which likely will suit a broader spectrum of buyers.

Neither of these cars lit up the test track with performance. Each car comes standard with a six-speed manual transmission in base form—which amounts to a budget-friendly $15,625 for the Versa and a still-thrifty $16,605 for the Yaris—but we much prefer the refined action of the Mazda's optional six-speed automatic over the Nissan's optional continuously variable automatic.