The Best Cars (and Trucks) for the Buck

Forbes

Honda CR-V

Honda CR-V

Consumers always seem to be overly focused on getting a great price for their purchases. But if you get a great deal on a pair of designer shoes, and you don’t wear them because they hurt your feet, were they really a good deal?

The same thing applies to shopping for a new car. “You can cut an amazing deal, but it’s not an amazing deal if you hate the car,” says Mike Quincy, an automotive specialist at Consumer Reports. “If it’s noisy, or you don’t fit in it comfortably, or it uses too much gas, it’s not a great deal.” As much as I love the looks of the Chevy Camaro, for instance, I would never buy it because the doors are too heavy and wide and they tend to smack into adjacent vehicles.

Buying a car is thus a very personal decision and there are many factors you should consider. But if a great value is what you’re after, a good rule of thumb is to look for cars with the best history of reliability and the lowest overall cost of ownership. Once you drive off the lot, the cost of ownership determines the true price you paid. Depreciation alone accounts for 46% of total ownership costs over five years; fuel typically accounts for 26%.

Think about how long you’re going to keep the car. If you plan on trading it in in a few years, you’ll want to make sure it will hold its value. On the other hand, if you’re planning to drive your car into the ground, depreciation doesn’t matter after a while.

Hyundai Santa Fe

Hyundai Santa Fe

We ranked the best cars for the money using reliability and ownership cost data from Consumer Reports. First we selected vehicles with the five highest reliability ratings in their segments (small car, family car, luxury car, SUV, etc.); then we evaluated their ownership costs. Then we chose the vehicles with the best balance between predicted reliability and low ownership costs in their respective segments to come up with our list of the best cars for the buck. It’s not an exhaustive list; but it’s a good place to start.

Reliability history is derived from Consumer Reports’ survey of 8 million subscribers, who evaluate their car’s performance over 12 months. It does not include the separate performance ratings assigned to vehicles by Consumer Reports’ own test drivers. Sometimes a car with proven reliability, like the Hyundai Elantra, doesn’t even show up on Consumer Reports’ recommended list. Driving impressions matter, but none more than your own.

Ownership costs were tallied over five years, consisting of sales tax (a national average of 4.9%), depreciation, fuel costs, interest (a five-year loan with a 15% down payment and an average interest rate of 6.8%), insurance, maintenance and repairs.

What we found is that the lowest-priced car isn’t always the best value.

Honda Fit

Honda Fit

A Honda Fit sport, for example, carries an MSRP of $16,860, about $3,100 more than the similarly sized Toyota Yaris. But when you factor in the cost of ownership over time, the Fit is actually a tad cheaper.

Among large utility vehicles, the $40,495 sticker price on an all-wheel-drive Ford Flex crossover is about the same as a Toyota Sequoia, but the fuel-efficiency of its Ecoboost engine means the Flex will cost about $14,000 less to own over five years. That’s definitely worth considering.

Other best bets in their respective category include the Ford Fusion hybrid (family cars), Honda CR-V (small SUVs) and Hyundai Santa Fe (mid-sized SUVs). All are predicted to be reliable in the future, with relatively low costs of ownership.

Whatever you do, says Quincy, choose a car that makes you happy. “You’re going to be cutting a check every month to pay for this car.” He said. “If you don’t like it, you’re just going to resent the heck out of that car.”

Best cars for the buck:
Mazda MX-5 Miata

Mazda MX-5 Miata


Honda Fit (MSRP: $16,860. 5-year cost: $27,250)
Acura TL (MSRP: $35,605. 5-year cost: $46,750)
Ford Fusion Hybrid (MSRP: $28,600 5-year cost: $38,250)
Mazda MX-5 Miata (MSRP: $23,110 5-year-cost: $38,250)
Volkswagen Jetta Sportwagen (MSRP: $23,745 5-year cost: $37,250)
Honda CR-V (MSRP: $21,895 5-year cost: $37,250)
Hyundai Santa Fe V6 SE (MSRP: $25,995 5-year cost: $44,500)
Acura RDX (MSRP: $32,895 5-year cost: $51,750)
Ford Flex AWD Ecoboost (MSRP: $40,495 5-year cost: $52,000)
Toyota Tundra V8 4WD (MSRP: $29,630 5-year cost: $51,750)

Full List: The Best Cars For The Buck
View Comments