Search

Lexus tops as survey finds more auto dependability

Lexus scored the best out of 32 brands, while Chrysler fared the worst.Lexus scored the best out of 32 brands, while Chrysler fared the worst.
Lexus
is the top performer in a survey of vehicle dependability released Wednesday, but most other brands also showed improvement in an industry that has reached historically high dependability levels.

Consulting firm J.D. Power and Associates polled 31,000 owners of 2009 model-year vehicles and rated brands by the number of problems owners have experienced in the last 12 months. Problems can range from stalling engines and transmission issues to peeling paint and electronics glitches.

Toyota PriusToyota PriusThe top complaint in this year's survey was excessive wind noise, followed by noisy brakes.

Lexus owners reported 86 problems per 100 vehicles. Porsche, Cadillac, Toyota and Scion rounded out the top five. The worst performers were Chrysler, Dodge, Jeep, Ram and Jaguar. Chrysler owners reported 192 problems per 100 vehicles.

The industry average was 132 problems per 100 vehicles, a 13 percent improvement from last year and the highest rate since the survey began in 1990. The results are particularly surprising since the industry was in turmoil in 2009. Both General Motors Co. and Chrysler Group LLC went through bankruptcy that year, and U.S. auto sales fell to a 30-year low because of the recession.

Cadillac CTSCadillac CTS"Despite facing immense challenges in 2009, automakers placed a keen focus on delivering outstanding levels of quality, which they understood would be essential to their long-term success," J.D. Power automotive vice president David Sargent said in a statement.

J.D. Power said 25 of 32 brands improved their scores, with Scion and Mini making the biggest leaps. Lincoln, Acura, Kia, Infiniti, Ram and Jaguar all saw their scores fall from a year ago. Buick's score stayed the same.

Mini CooperMini CooperToyota Motor Corp. had eight winners at the segment level, the most of any automaker. The Toyota Yaris was the most dependable subcompact, the Toyota Prius was the best compact and the Toyota Tundra was the best pickup truck. Toyota began a series of safety recalls in late 2009, and some 2009 model-year vehicles were included in those recalls, but that wasn't reflected in the company's results.

Ford Motor Co. had three segment winners, including the Ford Fusion midsize car and Ford Explorer SUV, while General Motors Co. and Nissan Motor Co. had two winners each.

 
  • Weapon-X  •  1 month 18 days ago
    Nice Work Lexus! I work for TOYOTA and I'm so proud of LEXUS achievements...
  • slipkidd  •  3 months ago
    NO LINK TO THE LIST AND RANK??? JUST BITS AND PIECES. WHAT A CRUMMY REPORT
    • Just Cirroc 3 months ago
      I was looking for the link too...
    • Observer 3 months ago
      Perhaps it was assumed you had basic internet skills...
    • Winton H 3 months ago
      As we said when I lived in NY, "WHAT A JIP!"
  • Mark H  •  Denver, Colorado  •  3 months ago
    Since when is dependability measured after 12 months? Any car that has trouble that soon is a true piece of junk.

    The ratings that matter are 3, 4 or 5 years after purchase. That's real world dependability, the kind that matters to most people.
    • Leroy 3 months ago
      These were 2009 model year cars which is more than 12 months.
    • Lucas E 3 months ago
      I agree. Dependability cant be measured in months but in years. I think any vehicle should be revisited after 10 years to see any common problems such has blown head gaskets, electrical faults, mechanical failures, etc. Show us a car that can last 10 years while having all services up to date, with MINIMUM repair cost (under $1000 over a 10 year period). That is what Americans want to see Detroit.
    • Chris 3 months ago
      "Consulting firm J.D. Power and Associates polled 31,000 owners of 2009 model-year vehicles and rated brands by the number of problems owners have experienced in the last 12 months."
  • William S  •  3 months ago
    What does wind noise have to do with reliability? Isn't that more of an "Initial Quality" issue? To me, reliablility means it won't leave you stranded, and rarely visits the shop.
    • Matt 3 months ago
      Well said William
    • Cromwell 3 months ago
      It just says it was a "complaint", it doesn't say it was used to judge reliability.
    • Willie Johnson 3 months ago
      Rich people can be insane I work at lexus and we get people coming in complaining about the dumbest noises. ITS A CAR NOT A SEALED TOMB. It's gonna have noises...
  • Mike Hunt  •  Austin, Texas  •  3 months ago
    "Problems can range from stalling engines and transmission issues to peeling paint and electronics glitches." But the top complaint is wind and brake noise? Is Chris Chase writing automovtive articles?
    • 13nvnt 3 months ago
      Question is ....Why Is Chris Chase writing automovtive articles?
    • aware 3 months ago
      chris is paid by these big 3 so is JD Powers
    • blueoval62 3 months ago
      Could be Jay Busbee, he's the biggest idiot automotive writer Yahoo has.
  • The Morning Shift  •  Los Angeles, California  •  3 months ago
    If you want to see a true testament of reliable cars, visit Havana Cuba.
    • max 3 months ago
      LOL!
    • bobh 3 months ago
      That's where all the older american cars went.
    • BobH 3 months ago
      I enjoyed your comment, reader, but to give a serious response, those pre-Castro American cars were actually not nearly as reliable as today's cars. Engines (and oils) were far short of today's standards. However, if you can't get a replacement, you can make any car last forever, which is what has happened in Cuba.
  • motor  •  3 months ago
    1979 chev g20 van with 360k on the odo. regularly gets 18mpg hwy. and this is a 6000 lb tank of a rig nothin like a good ol carbureted no bells and whistles vehicle to be genuinely reliable. The more usless frilly lazy butt electronics you add to ANY vehicle the more inherently unreliable it is period.
  • Toby  •  Atlanta, Georgia  •  3 months ago
    I have a 2006 Volvo S40 and I've never had a car with more problems than it. I just picked it up from the shop yet again with a $600.00 bill. Its been in the shop atleast 10 times in the 6 years I've owned it. Everything from th steering column to the air compressor has failed on it. Worst car I've ever owned.... So would be car shoppers..... DO NOT BUY VOLVO
  • Anthony  •  Tampa, Florida  •  3 months ago
    OK I will throw in my 2003 Cadillac De Ville with 324,000. I also own a 1999 Chevy K1500 with 212,000. Start with quality and perform a proper maintenance and your vehicles can go a LONG way!
  • Lt Keefer  •  Austin, Texas  •  3 months ago
    I would like to see the whole list.
  • jimster  •  3 months ago
    How about looking at cars several years old say five to fifteen years and see which ones are still dependable in stead of new ones.
  • BR  •  3 months ago
    I've been driving old Mercury Grand Marquis' for many years, always buy them with 70-80 thousand and usually triple that before getting rid of them. Never have stuck much money in them, normal maintenance and have enjoyed the rides of the big four door sedan. I know that if you need a repair on a ten year old Lexus it's going to cost big $'s.
  • kidsneeddiscipline  •  3 months ago
    Most people don't take basic care of their cars then wonder why things tend to fall apart after a couple years. Owner/driver error is incredibly high, some of the stuff I've seen as a mechanic just makes me shake my head.
  • QualitySilkPlants  •  Richardson, Texas  •  3 months ago
    Why did they have the Mini Cooper picture and there was nothing mentioned about it?
  • More S  •  Monroe, Louisiana  •  3 months ago
    JD Powers is not a credible source. They are in bed with the automakers.
  • JohnC  •  Southfield, Michigan  •  3 months ago
    How many of those people had problems with ALL the cars they have owned!
  • Michael  •  San Diego, California  •  3 months ago
    I have a 2000 Ford Expediton and it has 249,000 miles and still running strong. No major repairs. Original Engine and Tranny. I also own 2006 Dodge RAM and no problems with the truck. It's all about how we maintain our cars.
  • todd  •  3 months ago
    I am so tired of the people who claim their Toyota is more "American" than GM or Ford. NO, it's a car company owned by a FOREIGN country. This is not difficult people. I am sorry it is just too hard for you to grasp, but Japanese cars are NOT American.
  • loveLA  •  Monterey Park, California  •  3 months ago
    My old early 70's Ford LTD just keeps goin, and goin. . it uses more fuel in a month to make a car payment. i won't buy new because nothing is worth buying. I'll keep my classic intsead.
  • GencoOliveOilCompany  •  College Point, New York  •  3 months ago
    I have a 2002 Buick LeSabre that runs like a CHAMP. Tough miles driving in NYC, too. Not one major engine problem. Only typical city-driving repairs once in a while. I don't know what Buick was thinking when they aced the LeSabre and Century models.

Follow Yahoo! Autos

RESEARCH A CAR

Top Rated

Category: Sedans

More Articles

  • Most improved cars 2012 Marco R. della Cava

    Total Car Score recently released a list of Most Improved Cars for 2012, highlighting eight redesigned automobiles whose improvements helped the models’ scores jump significantly over 2011.

  • Memorial Day means many things to Americans: An opportunity to remember those who've died in service of their country. A chance to get together with friends and relatives. Cookouts. Picnics. Box socials. (They still have those, right?)

  • Take one look at these purpose-built sports cars and you'd expect them to be fast. You would be wrong. Even before we got used to powerful V6 Camrys, these ten rides chosen by Jalopnik readers were the slowest sports cars the world had ever seen.

  • "High performance" and "fuel efficient" need not be mutually exclusive terms, thanks to some truly quick cars that get surprisingly respectable mileage.

  • One of the most widely accepted bits of advice you’ll find presented in practically every consumer magazine as Wisdom From Upon High is a bad idea.