Search

The over-40 mpg club: Overachievers that beat EPA fuel economy ratings

The Honda Civic LX showed the most difference in mpg from EPA ratings. The Honda Civic LX showed the most difference in mpg from EPA ratings.

MORE FROM CONSUMER REPORTS

We’ve recently showed that most fuel-efficient cars can beat their EPA highway fuel economy estimates in Consumer Reports measured fuel economy testing. But if you want to hit 40 mpg on the highway, our tests show that you have more options than you might think.

Below is a list of recently tested vehicles that returned 40 mpg or better in our 65-mph highway fuel economy testing, but were officially rated for less.


Make & Model
EPA Highway MPG
CR Highway MPG
Difference (MPG)
Honda Civic LX
39
47
8
Honda Civic EX
39
43
4
Ford Fiesta SE sedan
38
45
6
Ford Focus SE
38
43
5
Toyota Camry Hybrid XLE
38
43
5
Fiat 500 Sport (manual)
38
42
4
Fiat 500C Pop (manual)
38
42
4
Nissan Versa SV sedan
38
40
2
Honda CR-Z EX (manual)
37
45
8
Ford Fiesta SES hatchback (manual)
38
42
4
Mini Cooper (manual)
37
41
4
BMW 335d
36
40
4
Ford Fusion Hybrid
36
40
4
Toyota Camry LE
35
41
6
Mazda2 Sport (manual)
35
40
5
Toyota Corolla LE
34
40
6
Scion xD (manual)
33
40
7

If getting that magic 40 mpg on the highway is important to you, this list provides more options.

Again, it’s important to emphasize that maximizing fuel economy depends a lot on how and where you drive.

Several years ago we measured fuel economy with a 2005 Toyota Camry four-cylinder sedan in different situations. Driving at 65 mph delivered 35 mpg; speeding up to 75 mph cut that to 30 mpg, while slowing down to 55 mph returned 40 mpg. Hard acceleration and braking reduced the Camry’s mileage by 2 to 3 mpg.

The bottom line


EPA highway fuel economy numbers provide a place to start your comparison shopping, but they’re often over-hyped as advertising claims. The full fuel picture is more complicated than that. We suggest using a variety of sources, including Consumer Reports test data, to determine if you’ll actually get the fuel economy you desire.

 
  • Jerry  •  East Syracuse, New York  •  2 months ago
    tdi is diesel overseas most cars are diesel tree huggers do not want diesels that get better
    mileage than gas an big oil only raise the cost of diesel whiich should cost less than gas because it is a by product of gas we are being hosed by big oil
  • CWLE  •  Stroudsburg, Pennsylvania  •  3 months ago
    I have a VW Jetta TDI and when I first got it I averaged 50 mpg. Now with 167,000 miles on and having to use the low sulfur fuel I still get at least 45 mpg even on a bad fill. There are lots of cars available in Europe that get 65 mpg, however our government will not let the car companies sell them here.
    • Sarah 3 months ago
      How's the reliability been on your jetta? ive been considering the TDI but it will have to last me at least 200,000 and I don't want to deal with lots of repair bills.
    • Douglas 3 months ago
      I have a 09 TDI jetta and it is stunning, every conseivable engineering problem has been addressed on this car, I get 41,42 mpg every tank, Thank the Lord for Volkswagen !
    • mark r 3 months ago
      The gas mileage is good on the TDI's, but the build quality of the rest of the car sucks, and VW will not do anything to fix bad design/quality issues. I love the gas mileage of my car, but I will NEVER EVER buy another VW. VW does not care abotu their customers all they want is the intial sell money and after that you are on your own. DO NOT EVER BUY A VW!!!
  • Truth hurts  •  Lake Success, New York  •  3 months ago
    I wish there is such thing called EPA for politicians.

    We really can get to know what was told and what was achieved leave alone over achievement.

    That would giv.e us all an idea about their political mileage in MPL (Miles Per Lie).
    • CoyoteMan 2 months ago
      Yeah Washington DC sure needs a hot air standard.
      :))
  • Fcrivera  •  3 months ago
    Now if only our government could overachieve in lowering gas prices!
    • Stephen 2 months ago
      the government doesn't control gas prices, wall street and the international market does
    • Danny 2 months ago
      government could control wall street and the international maket , as well, by controling trade guidelines on oil futures
  • Sw  •  Nashville, Tennessee  •  3 months ago
    I see no VW's diesels on the list and the people I know that drive the VW diesels get better mileage than the EPA projected. I drive an 05 Passet Wagon and it beats the EPA.
    • mark r 3 months ago
      Wait til you have a design flaw/problem and VW tells you there is nothing they can do for you. I will never buy another VW, NEVER.
    • jack 3 months ago
      Problems with Diesels in the USA is that Diesel is more expensive than reg. gas... at least in my area... not really worth it for me...
    • ME 3 months ago
      I think that diesel is considered an "alternative fuel", but I'm sold. The next new car I buy is going to be a clean diesel. If you do the math, I think it's worth a little more per gallon for all the extra miles you get out of it.
  • James K  •  3 months ago
    Remeber the vw rabbit diesel of the late 70's, that thing easily got 50mpg...so why did the mpg get less over the years, hell our old 73 beetle got 38 on a carb engine
    • GetReal 3 months ago
      Because the loudest stupid customers asked for more room and power for their Rabbits and the manufacturer obliged and ruined a good design as always. Whenever a good fuel efficient compact is popular, it's almost always ruined by the stupid customers asking for more instead of just buying a different bigger model.
    • Bill S 3 months ago
      Because with the combination of emissions control devices, and people thinking that they need to drive 100mph, larger engines were installed bringing fuel saving vehicle technology to an end.
    • David 3 months ago
      You can't beat the older Beetles for economic driving pleasure. I drove a '55 Beetle with one of those clothe sunroofs in the mid-60's when I was in college. It went a LONG way on that .29 a gallon gas. Nothing at all like the gashog Beetle that VW tried to fool us with recently.
  • Scott  •  Atlanta, Georgia  •  3 months ago
    I have a 2011 Santa Fe that regularly beats it's fuel rating of 26 highway, 22 city. I've been able to easily get 28 mpg on the highway and have gotten it to 30. City is even better regularly staying at 24.5 to 25 mpg. ANd it's a 6 cylinder with 276 HP.
  • weeniedawg  •  Santa Rosa Beach, Florida  •  3 months ago
    How you drive and where you drive has as much to do with fuel economy as other factors. I get better mileage than the stupid government ratings on every vehicle I own.
  • jR  •  3 months ago
    With $4/gal gas now upon us...40 mpg...will NOT be efficient enough for most Americans to keep up their present drivng habits...myself included..my work commute is 350 mi/week. Present vehicle gets 24mpg, now $60/wk...at $5 gal will be $90/wk!
  • RobertG  •  Orono, Maine  •  3 months ago
    You might also want to consider this. My Honda civic also over achieved in mpg then I discovered that my odometer was over indicating my mileage by 5%. A 10 mile test distance on the highway registered 10.5 miles on my odometer. A 38 mpg will look like 40 mpg with this 5% error. Maybe not the whole story but suspiciously part of it.
  • boosted96EX  •  3 months ago
    tiny little cars with tiny little engines better get good gas mileage.
  • Wayne  •  Tucson, Arizona  •  3 months ago
    OK, OK, my Mercedes E320 diesel only gets 36 mpg on the highway, but I think that's pretty respectable for a "luxury" car.
  • Owain Glyndwr  •  3 months ago
    40 mpg is a joke...........the Ford Fiesta with the common-rail diesel engine will get 65mpg easily.........and there are many more European cars that do just as well. The new diesel technology is clean and efficient and performs well. Hybrids are expensive nonsense that are not green or very efficient.
  • Brett p  •  Tacoma, Washington  •  3 months ago
    My Volkswagen Jetta TDI (Diesel) states 42 mpg highway. I've gotten as high as 51.7 mpg on my 34 mile trips to work. I routinely get 45-47 mpg driving freeway speeds. It's been a solid car thru 36k
  • The Messenger  •  Palm Beach, Florida  •  2 months ago
    if you could buy 100% gas and not the watered down ethanol stuff, we'd all get better gas mileage
  • Ryan  •  Southfield, Michigan  •  3 months ago
    i just got a 2012 Ford Fusion 4 cyl. got 36.6 MPG on highway doing 71mph for 180mile trip rated at 33mpg i loved it.
  • what a lot of hooey  •  3 months ago
    My 1981 toyota with a carburator got 36mpg without even trying. Look how far we've come in 30 years. Zilch. We need more small diesels and a better way to make the big trucks pay for the roads they eat other than taxing the living crap out of cheap diesel fuel for the every day driver.
  • Ashley  •  Ellettsville, Indiana  •  2 months ago
    Goes to show you how the media likes to shape mass opinion. I have a 2005 jetta TDI that has beaten the highway rating every single tank since ive owned it. I would get 50-53 on the old diesel fuel. What an absolute joke that this car gets left off the list!!!!
  • danielb  •  Nazareth, Pennsylvania  •  2 months ago
    All cars get get better than the MPG posted because what is posted is an average. I am a gas misser that still goes through about 4 gal per day all year round. The summer/winter blend makes a huge difference as well as the blend at different stations.
  • Arnold  •  3 months ago
    In the late 70s I bought a used 71 Datsun (before they became Nissan, right?) with an A block engine and a four speed. After I rebuilt the engine (with a few modifications by yours truly), installed a 5 speed out of a newer wreck and did some fiddling with both ignition and valve timing it got over 50mpg overall and nearly 60mpg on a long trip where I drove almost exclusively highway.
    My grandfather did the same with a 74 A block Datsun (except he already had a 5 speed) and got over 50 mpg as well.
    I really don't see the significance of a hybrid getting 30-40 mpg now. With the advances since the 70s and 'better' engineers than two mechanics that don't know you can't do that they should be doing a lot better. The idea that the hybrids don't pollute as much is killed by the mileage, since we got a minimum of 25% better efficiency on gas.

Follow Yahoo! Autos

RESEARCH A CAR

Top Rated

Category: Sedans

More Articles

  • Most improved cars 2012 Marco R. della Cava

    Total Car Score recently released a list of Most Improved Cars for 2012, highlighting eight redesigned automobiles whose improvements helped the models’ scores jump significantly over 2011.

  • Memorial Day means many things to Americans: An opportunity to remember those who've died in service of their country. A chance to get together with friends and relatives. Cookouts. Picnics. Box socials. (They still have those, right?)

  • Take one look at these purpose-built sports cars and you'd expect them to be fast. You would be wrong. Even before we got used to powerful V6 Camrys, these ten rides chosen by Jalopnik readers were the slowest sports cars the world had ever seen.

  • "High performance" and "fuel efficient" need not be mutually exclusive terms, thanks to some truly quick cars that get surprisingly respectable mileage.

  • One of the most widely accepted bits of advice you’ll find presented in practically every consumer magazine as Wisdom From Upon High is a bad idea.