Which Type of Car Wash Soap Is Best? We Wade through the Suds to Find Out

"Hearst Magazines and Yahoo may earn commission or revenue on some items through these links."

No spring car-cleaning adventure is complete without some good carwash soap. Pour it in a bucket, suds it up, and enjoy a warm Saturday morning—sounds great, right? Still, choosing which carwash soap you need can make or break your ride's shine.

While all carwashes claim to be different, special, or otherwise better than the rest, at the end of the day, car soap has one job to do: clean the car. Which brand or type you prefer is largely subjective, and besides, an informal office poll made it clear to us that most car lovers buy the brands we know and love, regardless of the marketing jargon thrown our way.

So when you run to the store to grab a new bottle, which kind of car soap should you buy? That's what we set out to find in this test of the best carwash soaps.

Looking for more car cleaning and detailing? The Gear Team has tested a number of car cleaning products, including best car vacuums, best car glass cleaners, and best car upholstery cleaners.

Our Quest for the Best Car Wash Soap

For professional insight into the world of car washing, we reached out to detailer and YouTube personality Larry Kosilla, founder of AMMO NYC. "I've been obsessed with cleaning cars and fanatical about them for a very long time," he says.

It quickly became apparent while researching and preparing for this test that objectively comparing 15 to 20 different carwash soaps and their various types and iterations was unrealistic—the choices are so vast and varied, and preferences so subjective to the user, that we'd effectively be comparing apples to oranges. Instead, we broke car soaps down into four main subsections.

Types of Car Wash Soap

Many of today's carwash soaps go beyond simple cleanser. After considering dozens of car-washing products, our research showed that the majority of car soaps these days fall into one of four main types:

• Regular carwash soap

• Carwash soap with wax

• Hybrid carwash soap

• Ceramic carwash soap

Each type has its abilities and drawbacks, and all have their pros and cons. With so many claims and promises, just scoping the shelves can be overwhelming. Comparing them? Downright impossible.

So instead of resolutely pronouncing that "this soap works better than that one" or objectively naming one "the best," we're here to help explain and differentiate between each of these four main types of carwashing soap.

Things to Consider When Buying Car Wash Soap

There are lots of factors to consider when buying carwash, but the number-one issue, according to Kosilla, is "What are you trying to clean?" There are soaps for almost every component and material on your car. For this comparison, we'll stick to general carwash soaps, not component cleaners. Here's what to look for.

pH Balance: In general, look for a soap that's pH-balanced to ensure it cleans the whole car without damaging wax, paintwork, or components. Depending on where you live and how you drive, though, there may be other pH considerations.

"If you're in Alaska where you have lots of road salt," says Kosilla, "you might want to get something that has a lower pH, to attack the minerals and remove the salts from the surface, just like you would on your hair. If you're in Florida and the roads have tar and it's a hundred thousand degrees or whatever, you're going to want a high-pH-based soap." But these are extremes; for the most part, Kosilla says, a neutral pH balance is your best bet. "pH neutral soaps are the safest and are not going to do anything drastic to the paint or whatever is covering the paint," says Kosilla.

Concentration/Value: A more concentrated soap will last longer and potentially offer better value for money, depending on the price-per-ounce and dilution requirements. Use some basic math to check how much product is required for each wash to determine the rough per-wash price.

Compatibility with Washing Tools: Take into consideration the tools you have on hand and your personal preference for washing your car. Some soaps are specially formulated for use with foam guns or cannons, while others are best applied by hand.

Environmental Impact: Many brands now offer eco-friendly options with fewer compromises on cleaning power and functionality. Look for biodegradable formulas to be environmentally conscious.

Finish and Protection: Besides cleaning, consider what additional benefits the soap offers, such as added wax for protection or ingredients that enhance shine.

Additives: Counterintuitively, if you plan to add a wax or ceramic coating after your carwash, it might make more sense to buy regular car soap to get your car completely clean before you spiff it up with other products. Otherwise, you'll end up applying additional wax or ceramic coating on top of the stuff that's already in the soap.

Washing Method: As Kosilla noted, carwashing "is so much more important than the actual product. We can argue about the products all day long," Larry admits, "but if you have the best product in the world and have a horrible method, the soap doesn't matter."

To avoid spreading contaminants, you'll want to make sure you're minimizing the risk of grinding dirt and debris into the car. As such, you'll want to use one of two washing methods: the two-bucket method or utilize a grit guard. The two-bucket method utilizes one bucket for your soap solution and one for rinsing your wash mitt. A grit guard fits at the bottom of a bucket to help trap contaminants that may scratch your ride's paint.

At the end of the day, Kosilla admits the distinctions between carwash soaps are often cosmetic rather than chemical. "For the average person that just wants to wash their regular car that they use for regular things, all carwashes are more or less in the same ballpark—what you're changing is some lubrication. Definitely fragrance, definitely colors and things. And obviously the biggest one of all is price," he says.

"Everybody's focused on what's the cheapest," Kosilla says, "but when people are focused on price only, that's what they're going to get."

How We Tested Car Wash Soap

Rather than pit all these types of carwash soaps with varying additives, ingredients, and purposes against each other to try and determine "the best," we decided instead to compare each type of carwash soap to evaluate the merits and drawbacks of each: one brand, four types of soap, four products.

Because Mothers Polish offers a carwash soap in each type—and, for the record, is not an advertiser with Hearst Autos—we chose that brand's soaps for this comparison. For kicks, we even tested common dish soap. After all, we know some of you out there still do it. (Spoiler alert: don't.)

We started by mixing soap and water as per the directions on each respective bottle, then washed one car panel per type using a classic bucket-and-mitt wash method with a grit guard. We dumped and rinsed our bucket between each wash.

As we washed each car, we noted the following parameters:

• Differences between each types

• Texture

• Cleaning power

• Amount of suds

Because we knew it would be impossible and unrealistic to compare 16 different carwashes to one another objectively, for this test we really set out to compare the four types of soaps to see if any differences were truly discernible. We also wanted to determine if any of them clearly stood above the rest.

Read on to learn the key characteristics of each type of soap, the features it offers (or claims to), and how you can choose the best carwash soap to help you clean like a pro.

Note: The products listed under each soap type are merely examples of each. We used Mothers' products as our baseline; the other car soaps are merely Gear Team recommendations.

Regular Carwash Soap

Let's start with the most basic, and typically cheapest, type of carwash soap. It's old school—lacking any sort of wax or ceramic additives that claim to be "new and improved." Just simple, sudsy goodness that won't break the bank. But how did it hold up against the new kids on the block?

Pretty darn well, as it turns out. Ironically, simple car soap might not be your idea of the "best" type of carwash soap, but it's usually among the go-to for detailers and professional car-care folks. Of course, the one downside to using pure car soap is a lack of protectants. This does cause the entire car-washing process to become longer, but pros know this is a good thing.

Because this kind of soap doesn't leave any additives behind, you can apply the wax or coating of your choice—which is nearly always better than the stuff included in soaps.

If this sounds like you, look into simple, no-frills, regular carwash soap. But if time is a concern when it comes to washing and waxing your ride, consider a carwash soap with additives.

Mothers 3X Triple Action Foam Wash

Meguiar's Gold Class Car Wash

Chemical Guys Mr. Pink Super Suds Shampoo Surface Cleaner

Adam's Mega Foam

Car Soap + Wax

Car soap and wax combos toe the line elegantly between price and efficiency. If you aren't concerned so much with having a perfect shine and simply want a clean look that also repels water and gunk, this is the stuff to get.

During our testing, the suds and water felt waxy—which actually dried our hands out a bit. The viscosity of this soap type is thicker and almost honey-like, so expect to mix it in with the water a bit more than you would with regular carwash soap.

As for the efficacy of these wax soaps, Kosilla says they offer extra protection and the added benefit of quicker drying. Once applied to the car and rinsed off, the water will bead off faster thanks to the wax additives. We detected only a very slight waxy finish on the paint afterward, far less than we expected to feel.

It's important to remember that while these carwash soaps claim to include "wax," whatever's here will never be as good as separate car-wax application. Keeping that in mind, it's better than nothing—so if you're short on time but want a waxy shine, grab some carwash soap + wax.

Mothers California Gold Carnauba Wash & Wax

Meguiar's Ultimate Wash & Wax

Chemical Guys Extreme Bodywash + Wax

3D Wash N Wax