I'm Trading My Tacoma For Two Cars! Which Ones Should I Buy?

Mike lives in Texas and using Jalop math has determined that it’s better to have two cars instead of just one. He will be selling his trusty Tacoma and wants to replace it with a reliable commuter and something fun for the weekends. With a combined budget of about $45,000, which cars should he buy?

(Welcome back to What Car Should You Buy? Where we give real people real advice about buying cars. Do you want us to help you find a car? Submit your story on our form.)

Read more

• SBF Made $9 Billion Disappear. This Forensic Accountant Found It

• Apple Reportedly Cancels Jon Stewart’s Show Over His AI and China Talking Points

• Is There Any Merit to the Lupita Nyong'o and Joshua Jackson Romance Rumors?

• Loki recap: Welcome to the Jonathan Majors show

• Spider-Man 2’s Graphics Are (Mostly) Improved Over The Original’s

Budget: Up to $45,00 for both

Location: Houston, TX

Daily Driver: Yes

Wants: Car 1 - Reliable, easy. Car 2- Fun, manual, small

Doesn’t want: A crossover

Expert 1: Tom McParland - New School + Old School

Mike, you are correct that it is better to have several vehicles each with their specific purpose over one car that tries to do it all. Though you could spend your total budget on a new GR Corolla and that would check all your boxes, since the market for that hot-hatch isn’t favorable, it’s best to split the budget.

For the commuter car, you want easy and low cost; in that case, it’s worth having a look at a lightly used Chevy Bolt. As we have mentioned before, these cars have had their batteries replaced so they benefit from an increase in range and most of them have a long warranty balance. You may also qualify for the tax credit on used cars making the net cost even lower. For example, here is a 2021 LT in an excellent color, barely used with only 1300 miles for about $18,000. When you factor in the tax savings your net cost gives you quite a bit leftover for the fun car.

Of course, that doesn’t mean you should blow the whole remainder on the weekend toy. Since the Bolt is more of a “high-tech” ride, something a bit simpler might be the ticket for when you really want to connect with your car. If you are willing to look beyond the Texas borders you will find more options especially if you need a manual. For example, this 2013 BMW 135 convertible is perfect for enjoying the open road. You’ll get a 300 hp twin-turbo inline-six mated to an excellent manual gearbox and rear-wheel drive. With less than 55,000 miles, this Bimmer looks really clean for only $17,000. That’s a lot of cash left over for German car maintenance, a home charging setup, and maybe even a nice getaway.