Five best used cars for teens

ConsumerReports.org

Choosing a car for a teen can be tough, as there are so many factors to consider. We emphasize safety, reliability, and ease of use for inexperienced drivers in making our ultimate recommendations.

We recently posted "Best used car deals for teens" featuring many affordable models that meet that criteria and are generally available for less than $15,000. This time, we're taking it a step further. Our automotive experts winnowed the list down to the five cars they would personally recommend, looking at traditional empirical data and their own subjective insights.

The vehicles on this short list are from the 2008-2010 model years and have at least average reliability, according to our latest subscriber survey. Some have the latest safety equipment and are still affordable but key safety features such as curtain air bags and electronic stability control (ESC) may not have been standard in others until later years. As always we encourage purchasing as many safety features--and electronic stability control in particular--as your budget allows.

We list the average price for suitably equipped models available in that year when buying from a dealer. On average, figure that vehicles from 2008 will generally have 66,000 miles, 2009 models around 51,000 miles, and 2010 about 40,000 miles.

The models selected are all traditional cars; large pickups and SUVs are not recommended for young, inexperienced drivers because they are more prone to roll over and may be more difficult to handle than many other vehicles. Sports cars increase the risk of speeding and have a higher rate of accidents, and consequently, they carry tuition-sapping and head-spinningly high insurance premiums.

Here's where to start your teenager-targeted used-car vehicle search:

Chevrolet Malibu
For 2008, Chevrolet redesigned the Malibu and made it much more competitive, producing a sedan that's quiet, handles responsively, and with a good ride. The base 169-horsepower, 2.4-liter four-cylinder engine paired with a four-speed automatic transmission delivered 23 mpg overall on regular fuel. The interior was significantly upgraded, with better materials and fit and finish. Not exciting, but a good solid car at an attractive price. Beginning in 2008, ESC was standard for most trim lines.

Make & model Average price buying from dealer Average drop in retail value vs. MSRP Used-car pricing
 2009 Chevrolet Malibu $12,925 45% View detailed pricing
 2010 Chevrolet Malibu $14,483 39% View detailed pricing

Hyundai Sonata
Electronic stability control and curtain air bags are standard in these used models. The base 162-hp, 2.4-liter four-cylinder in the 2008 model delivers adequate performance and returns 23 mpg overall. For 2009, the Sonata got a stylish redesign with a 175-hp, 2.4-liter four-cylinder engine. While a bit slower than competing four-cylinders, it delivers impressive fuel economy with 26 mpg overall on regular fuel. The highway ride is quite relaxed and most noises are suppressed. Most controls are very simple.

Make & model Average price buying from dealer Average drop in retail value vs. MSRP Used-car pricing
 2008 Hyundai Sonata $9,917 51% View detailed pricing
 2009 Hyundai Sonata $11,167 50% View detailed pricing
 2010 Hyundai Sonata $13,317 40% View detailed pricing

Mazda6
The Mazda6 retained its sporty character with the 2009 redesign. Not only is the 6 fun to drive, it's also roomy and quiet. The four-cylinder engine returns a fairly economical 24 mpg overall. Handling is nimble. Road noise is a bit pronounced. The interior has a high-quality feel.

Make & model Average price buying from dealer Average drop in retail value vs. MSRP Used-car pricing
 2009 Mazda6 $10,800 49% View detailed pricing
 2010 Mazda6 $12,625 38% View detailed pricing

Ford Focus sedan
The Focus has agile handling, a composed ride, and a roomy interior, but fit and finish and noise remain weak points. The 130-hp, 2.0-liter four-cylinder engine delivers average performance and 26 mpg overall. It had a commendable speed in our avoidance maneuver. ESC became available starting with 2009 models and standard by 2010.

Make & model Average price buying from dealer Average drop in retail value vs. MSRP Used-car pricing
 2009 Ford Focus $10,388 38% View detailed pricing
 2010 Ford Focus $12,313 30% View detailed pricing

Volkswagen Jetta
This generation VW Jetta is a jewel; it is a beautifully finished, sharp-handling premium small car. The 170-hp, 2.5-liter five-cylinder engine delivers better-than-average performance and chalked up 24 mpg overall on regular fuel. A thrifty diesel engine is available. The five-cylinder 2009 model, in particular, has better-than-average reliability and standard ESC. Other strong points include a composed ride and roomy interior.
Crash test scores are good.

Make & model Average price buying from dealer Average drop in retail value vs. MSRP Used-car pricing
2009 Volkswagen Jetta $13,831 39% View detailed pricing

Buying a used car has many benefits. Most important is that the original owner takes the initial depreciation hit, as new cars lose much more value in the first and second years than those that follow. When shopping, look for cars that scored well in Consumer Reports' tests when new, have proven reliability, and perform well in government and insurance industry crash tests, just like the five models spotlighted here. Before handing over the cash, have the vehicle inspected by a trained and trusted mechanic to make sure there are no hidden problems.

See our complete list of used-car deals across a variety of vehicle categories. Also, see our list of best new and used cars for teens, as well as our special section on teen driving safety. For detailed used car pricing based on the mileage and condition of the vehicle, try Consumer Reports Used Car Price Reports.

—Liza Barth

More from Consumer Reports:
2013 New Car Preview
Best and worst used cars
Complete Ratings for 200 cars and trucks

Consumer Reports has no relationship with any advertisers or sponsors on this website. Copyright © 2007-2013 Consumers Union of U.S., Inc. No reproduction, in whole or in part, without written permission.

View Comments (354)

Recommended for You

  • The future look of Volkswagen? The Sport Coupe Concept GTE

    The Volkswagen Sport Concept Coupe GTE has five doors and a plug-in hybrid power system — but it's the exterior design that's most likely to see production.

    Motoramic
  • World's fastest car? Koenigsegg Regera makes an 1,800-hp case

    For $1.9 million, the Swedish supercar builder will sell you a machine that's capable of hitting 248 mph — in just 20 seconds.

    Motoramic
  • Bentley's surprise sports-car concept aims a fist at Jaguar, Porsche

    The stately British luxury carmaker unveils a concept for a two-seat ultra-expensive sports car

    Motoramic
  • Driving the Lamborghini LM002, Rambo's SUV

    The Mercedes-Benz G63 AMG is, at the moment, about the most exotic truck you can buy, a juiced-up former military vehicle that packs 536 horsepower and price tag deep in the six figures. Its reign will be short, for soon Mercedes will unveil the G65 AMG, with a twin-turbo V12 and a price that…

    Motoramic
  • McLaren Brings the Noise With its Latest Teaser

    As you know, this week was the Geneva Motor Show. And if you didn’t— where the heck have you been? But as Geneva winds to close, and in fact this was the 85th Geneva Motor Show, we can no look towards the future. Onward, to the New York Auto Show! Yes ladies and gentlemen, it’s

    Boldride
  • For $10,700, This 1960 Nash Metropolitan Will Steal Your Heart

    For a long time, I’ve been a fan of microcars. They’re just so adorable with their tiny little bodies and cute little engines. And after some late night browsing, this 1960 Nash Metropolitan is the latest object of my affection. With an all black getup, this example has 49,000 miles on the odometer…

    Boldride
  • Red Bull Explains What Skijoring Is In The Best Way Possible

    The venerable Wikipedia defines skijoring as a winter sport where a person on skis is pulled by a horse, a dog (or dogs) or a motor vehicle. Red Bull has been kind enough to give us a prime example of the awesome sport—and boy, do we want to see this in the

    RideApart.com
  • Ford Mustang Drifts The Abandoned City Of Ordos: Video

    If you’re like us, you’re not exactly up on your animal-based calendars. Fortunately, Ford is—and it’s the Year of the Horse. Naturally, that’s a perfect fit for the Mustang—new again this year.

    MotorAuthority
  • Check Out Harley-Davidson’s Electric Motorcycle in the New ‘Avengers’ Trailer

    The latest trailer for Avengers: Age of Ultron is here, and it’s full of all the glorious superhero antics one would expect. There are crazy stunts, massive amounts of property destruction, and one very cool looking Harley-Davidson. This particular Harley belongs to Black Widow and it’s not any old…

    Boldride
  • Drive Review: 2015 Hyundai Genesis - A Glorified Sonata?

    As someone firmly entrenched in the world of auto writer-dom, it’s expected of me to get all hot and bothered about the Hyundai Genesis sedan. After all, it’s big, bold and brash, it’s got a sport-tuned chassis, and most importantly of all, it’s rear-wheel

    RideApart.com
  • Bold Ride’s 5 Favorite Cars From the 2015 Geneva Motor Show

    The Koenigsegg Regera hybrid megacar won the 2015 Geneva International Motor Show. If you say otherwise, just do everybody a favor and stop trying to be different for the sake of being different. Now that we have that out of the way, let’s talk about everything else that was at the show. Because…

    Boldride
  • This is Indian Motorcycle's "Mark Wahlberg Collection" Clothing Line

    The former Marky Mark is the typical Boston tough guy and above all, a motorcycling enthusiast, so it's no wonder Indian Motorcycles chose him as their brand ambassador. The Pain and Gain star is now leading the new Indian Motorcycles clothing line campaign

    RideApart.com
  • Ferrari Sergio Debuts At 2015 Geneva Motor Show

    It was at the 2013 Geneva Motor Show that Italian design legend Pininfarina rolled out the Sergio concept car (shown below) honoring its fallen patriarch Sergio Pininfarina who passed away one year prior. The concept proved so popular that Pininfarina, together with Ferrari whose 458 Spider was…

    MotorAuthority
  • New Ford GT Could Be Really Expensive and Really Exclusive

    All right everyone, you can stop holding your breath and start breaking out your wallets. We now have some rather important information regarding production and pricing of the new Ford GT. That said, it’s pretty controversial. Let’s see if we can make sense of it. Speaking at the Ford reception at…

    Boldride
  • This Life-sized Motorcycle Model Kit Should Be on Your Wishlist

    If you're looking for a cool motorcycle model to occupy your time, then look no further than Full Size Kits . As the name suggests, the UK-based company’s motorcycles are plastic, to-scale models. The company, which is headed by Peter Manning, sells the kits

    RideApart.com
  • Will Oil Price Collapse Because We're Out Of Room To Store It?

    Oil prices have dropped precipitously over the past few months, and while that's led to lower gas prices, it's also creating a somewhat unusual problem.

    Green Car Reports
  • 2015 Volkswagen e-Golf Electric Car Gets Less Expensive Trim Level

    When pricing for the 2015 Volkswagen e-Golf electric car was announced last August, only one trim level was available, a lavishly equipped top-of-the-range package. Now VW has supplemented that SEL Premium version of the e-Golf with a new, less expensive model called the Limited Edition, at a…

    Green Car Reports