Advertisement

These Used Cars Give You the Most Bang for Your Buck

  • Used car shoppers can get over 100,000 miles of use for less than $10,000 from the Chevrolet Impala

  • Toyota Prius is available for less than $14,000 with up to 130,000 miles of remaining life, along with exceptional fuel economy

  • SUVs and minivans, including the Honda Odyssey and Ford Expedition, can provide more than 100,000 miles of family transportation for just $15,000

  • Toyota Avalon can be purchased for less than $16,000 with over 143,000 miles of remaining lifespan

 

How can consumers get the most remaining life out of a used car while paying the lowest purchase price? Used car shoppers should consider one of these top 20 best used cars for the money. By analyzing over 2 million used vehicles, iSeeCars.com identified models with the longest lifespan and then compared those models with their current used car values. This allowed iSeeCars.com to identify the best values for 10-year-old vehicles ranked by the price of their remaining potential lifespan (the lowest price per remaining 1,000 miles of lifespan).

ADVERTISEMENT

“Although used car pricing is slowly dropping, it remains near record levels, putting a serious financial pinch on first-time buyers or used car shoppers needing to replace their current vehicle. And new vehicle pricing is simply unrealistic for many consumers,” said Karl Brauer, Executive Analyst for iSeeCars.com. “But we now know shoppers can buy a 10-year-old car that costs substantially less than 1-5 year-old used models, yet these vehicles still have 80,000 or more miles of life left in them,” continued Brauer. “Some, like the Toyota Prius, Toyota Avalon, and Honda Ridgeline, have more than 125,000 miles to go. And all of these top 20 cars provide a potential lifespan above 200,000 miles.”

Top 20 Best Used Cars for the Money: Wide Range of Brands and Vehicle Types

The average price for these top 20 best used cars for the money is just $12,814, with an average remaining lifespan of 101,923 miles, or more than 46% left of their total usable lifespan. This top 20 ranking also has a good mix of vehicles here, with everything from small hatchbacks to midsize sedans, three-row SUVs, minivans, and a pickup truck represented. 

Best Cars for the Money, 10-year-old Used Cars

Model

Price per 1k Miles

Avg Price

Remaining Lifespan (miles)

Remaining Lifespan (%)

Potential Lifespan (miles)

Chevrolet Impala

$87

$9,706

111,996

48.6%

230,343

Toyota Prius

$107

$13,878

129,466

51.7%

250,601

Honda Civic (coupe)

$108

$12,673

117,819

52.1%

226,120

Kia Sedona

$110

$9,640

87,747

42.1%

208,615

Toyota Avalon

$111

$15,818

143,056

58.2%

245,710

Honda Fit

$112

$12,347

110,333

53.2%

207,231

Honda Accord

$118

$13,437

113,584

50.2%

226,168

Ford Fusion

$119

$10,079

84,590

42.1%

201,071

Dodge Grand Caravan

$120

$10,354

86,292

41.2%

209,350

Toyota Camry Hybrid

$123

$14,360

116,903

50.7%

230,547

Mazda Mazda6

$124

$9,559

77,253

38.0%

203,154

Toyota Camry

$129

$13,785

106,682

47.8%

223,249

Toyota Corolla

$130

$12,658

97,621

47.8%

204,266

Hyundai Santa Fe

$131

$11,981

91,525

44.3%

206,398

Honda Civic (sedan)

$134

$12,784

95,596

46.6%

205,335

Nissan Maxima

$136

$11,398

83,709

41.4%

202,151

Honda Odyssey

$138

$14,790

106,879

45.3%

235,852

Ford Expedition

$143

$15,584

108,762

44.5%

244,682

Honda Ridgeline

$145

$18,725

129,513

52.1%

248,669

Toyota Sienna

$145

$16,289

112,578

47.0%

239,607

Average for All 10-Year-Old Cars

$157

$15,902

101,571

45.5%

223,402

Top 10 Best Used Cars for the Money: 5-Year-Old Models Still Offer Big Savings

Shoppers not comfortable buying a 10-year-old car can still find savings and plenty of remaining life by shopping for 5-year-old cars. Of course the average cost of these top 10 models is higher than a 10-year-old car, but still reasonable at $20,428 versus today’s used car price average of approximately $33,000, especially when the average remaining lifespan of 150,526 miles – or 69% of total lifespan remaining – is taken into account. 

Best Cars for the Money, 5-year-old Used Cars

Model

Price per 1k Miles

Avg Price

Remaining Lifespan (miles)

Remaining Lifespan (%)

Potential Lifespan (miles)

Honda Fit

$119

$18,486

154,826

74.7%

207,231

Honda Civic (coupe)

$130

$22,336

171,421

75.8%

226,120

Toyota Prius

$131

$24,208

185,049

73.8%

250,601

Toyota Camry

$133

$20,482

153,517

68.8%

223,249

Chevrolet Impala

$135

$20,318

150,807

65.5%

230,343

Toyota Corolla

$137

$18,661

136,543

66.8%

204,266

Toyota Avalon

$139

$26,104

187,385

76.3%

245,710

Honda Accord

$140

$22,450

160,370

70.9%

226,168

Toyota Camry Hybrid

$143

$22,977

160,288

69.5%

230,547

Ford Fusion

$144

$18,793

130,209

64.8%

201,071

Average for All 5-Year-Old-Cars

$193

$29,566

153,093

68.5%

223,402

Top 10 Best Used SUVs for the Money: Family Flexibility for Around $15,000

The cargo space and functionality of SUVs and crossovers has made them popular over the past few years. Everything from a compact SUV like the CR-V to the exceedingly roomy Chevrolet Suburban makes the list. Most of these models are available with all-wheel drive to bolster confidence in cold-weather states.

Best SUVs for the Money, 10-year-old Used Cars

Model

Price per 1k Miles

Avg Price

Remaining Lifespan (miles)

Remaining Lifespan (%)

Potential Lifespan (miles)

Hyundai Santa Fe

$131

$11,981

91,525

44.3%

206,398

Ford Expedition

$143

$15,584

108,762

44.5%

244,682

Honda Pilot

$147

$15,214

103,305

43.6%

236,807

Acura MDX

$151

$16,522

109,710

48.0%

228,472

Subaru Outback

$152

$12,782

84,348

40.5%

208,298

Honda CR-V

$152

$15,540

102,190

47.3%

215,930

Mazda CX-9

$154

$12,330

80,264

39.7%

201,972

Toyota Sequoia

$154

$23,310

151,360

51.0%

296,509

Chevrolet Suburban

$159

$18,144

114,323

43.0%

265,732

Ford Edge

$160

$12,741

79,627

39.1%

203,662

SUV Segment Average

$166

$16,201

97,569

43.5%

224,512

Top 10 Best Used Trucks for the Money: All With Over 90,000 Miles of Use Left

Trucks face some of the toughest use cases of any vehicle, yet these 10 models can be purchased for an average of less than $20,000 while offering an average remaining lifespan of more than 100,000 miles.

Best Trucks for the Money, 10-year-old Used Cars

Model

Price per 1k Miles

Avg Price

Remaining Lifespan (miles)

Remaining Lifespan (%)

Potential Lifespan (miles)

Honda Ridgeline

$145

$18,725

129,513

52.1%

248,669

Chevrolet Colorado

$162

$15,277

94,256

47.0%

200,554

Nissan Frontier

$163

$16,891

103,383

47.9%

215,775

Nissan Titan

$166

$18,805

113,158

48.5%

233,295

Toyota Tundra

$180

$23,049

128,261

50.1%

256,022

Chevrolet Silverado 1500

$183

$19,220

104,829

45.5%

230,515

Toyota Tacoma

$187

$21,866

117,209

49.9%

235,070

Ford F-150

$199

$19,819

99,658

42.8%

232,650

Dodge/Ram 1500

$205

$18,864

91,870

42.6%

215,521

GMC Sierra 1500

$206

$19,758

96,132

43.2%

222,691

Truck Segment Average

$191

$19,552

102,437

44.9%

228,059

Top 4 Best Used Minivans for the Money: Plenty of People-Moving Still To Do

A wide spectrum of minivan pricing is available for used shoppers looking for maximum life at a minimum price. The Sedona starts things off below $10,000, and with more than 87,000 miles remaining, that price buys a lot of future use. The Toyota Sienna is the most expensive minivan, at $16,289, but it offers another 112,000 miles of people-toting to go.

Best Minivans for the Money, 10-year-old Used Cars

Model

Price per 1k Miles

Avg Price

Remaining Lifespan (miles)

Remaining Lifespan (%)

Potential Lifespan (miles)

Kia Sedona

$110

$9,640

87,747

42.1%

208,615

Dodge Grand Caravan

$120

$10,354

86,292

41.2%

209,350

Honda Odyssey

$138

$14,790

106,879

45.3%

235,852

Toyota Sienna

$145

$16,289

112,578

47.0%

239,607

Minivan Segment Average

$139

$13,753

99,135

43.9%

225,753

Top 10 Best Used Sedans and Hatchbacks for the Money: $12,000 will get you 100,000 Miles

Sedans and hatchbacks continue to offer an excellent blend of practicality and high mpg at a reasonable price. The best large cars are the Chevrolet Impala and Toyota Avalon, offering more than 230,000 potential miles. The best midsize car is the Honda Accord, with an average of 113,584 miles still on tap. The best compact cars are the Honda Civic and Toyota Corolla, both of which offer a potential lifespan over 200,000 miles.

Best Sedans/Hatchbacks for the Money, 10-year-old Used Cars

Model

Price per 1k Miles

Avg Price

Remaining Lifespan (miles)

Remaining Lifespan (%)

Potential Lifespan (miles)

Chevrolet Impala

$87

$9,706

111,996

48.6%

230,343

Toyota Avalon

$111

$15,818

143,056

58.2%

245,710

Honda Fit

$112

$12,347

110,333

53.2%

207,231

Honda Accord

$118

$13,437

113,584

50.2%

226,168

Ford Fusion

$119

$10,079

84,590

42.1%

201,071

Mazda Mazda6

$124

$9,559

77,253

38.0%

203,154

Toyota Camry

$129

$13,785

106,682

47.8%

223,249

Toyota Corolla

$130

$12,658

97,621

47.8%

204,266

Honda Civic (sedan)

$134

$12,784

95,596

46.6%

205,335

Nissan Maxima

$136

$11,398

83,709

41.4%

202,151

Sedan + Hatchback Segment Avg

$125

$12,583

100,419

47.1%

213,197

Top 9 Best Used Hybrids for the Money: Low Price and Low Ownership Cost

Hybrids are newer to the market and haven’t had as much time to accumulate miles, so we lowered the required potential lifespan to 150,000 miles to make our list. These nine hybrids offer an average remaining lifespan of 103,133 miles, and they can be purchased for an average cost under $14,000. And with excellent fuel efficiency, their operating cost will be low, too.

Best Hybrids for the Money, 10-year-old Used Cars

Model

Price per 1k Miles

Avg Price

Remaining Lifespan (miles)

Remaining Lifespan (%)

Potential Lifespan (miles)

Toyota Prius

$107

$13,878

129,466

51.7%

250,601

Toyota Camry Hybrid

$123

$14,360

116,903

50.7%

230,547

Hyundai Sonata Hybrid

$147

$10,948

74,452

40.3%

184,887

Kia Optima Hybrid

$157

$10,980

69,755

38.0%

183,632

Ford Fusion Hybrid

$158

$10,948

69,162

39.4%

175,670

Lincoln MKZ Hybrid

$159

$12,105

76,109

42.8%

177,678

Toyota Highlander Hybrid

$171

$19,214

112,584

46.0%

244,994

Lexus RX 450h

$238

$19,934

83,701

42.5%

196,826

Porsche Cayenne

$494

$21,364

43,205

28.3%

152,563

Hybrid Segment Avg

$132

$13,639

103,133

47.0%

219,528

Best Used Electric Cars for the Money: More Than a Decade of Proven History

Due to the recent introduction of electric vehicles we lowered the mileage threshold to 80,000, allowing the Tesla Model S and Nissan LEAF to make the cut. A 10-year-old Model S remains costly at an average price of $35,612, with a remaining potential lifespan of 55,025 miles. The Nissan Leaf has a much shorter electric driving range, but it can be purchased for $9,196 and still have 43,811 miles of emissions-free driving to give.

Best EVs for the Money, 10-year-old Used Cars

Model

Price per 1k Miles

Avg Price

Remaining Lifespan (miles)

Remaining Lifespan (%)

Potential Lifespan (miles)

Nissan LEAF

$210

$9,196

43,811

44.7%

98,081

Tesla Model S

$647

$35,612

55,025

41.1%

133,998

EV Segment Avg

$223

$13,636

61,021

51.1%

119,443

Compared to today’s average new car MSRP, and even the average dealership price tag of slightly used cars, the accessibility of these older models to budget-minded buyers is far greater. And these cars still offer reliable powertrains, 21st century safety features, and most modern infotainment features, such as Bluetooth streaming and navigation. 

Buyers in need of greater cargo or passenger capacity than a subcompact car or subcompact SUV provides can now consider the older, larger models on these lists. While newer cars like the Hyundai Kona or Nissan Versa are affordable, they may not serve larger families. But an older minivan or 3-row SUV, with 100,000 miles left on its lifespan, could be the solution to families on a tight budget.

Regardless of vehicle type, shoppers should always review a used car’s vehicle history report before buying, and a pre-purchase inspection is another prudent move when buying any used car, particularly an older vehicle.

More from iSeeCars:

Methodology

iSeeCars.com analyzed over 2 million used cars on the road between January and October of 2022. The mileage over which the top one percent of cars within each model obtained was calculated and used as an estimate of end-of-life for that model. The average five- and ten-year-old used car prices of each model, as well as the average mileage of five- and ten-year-old versions of each model, were then aggregated to calculate the cost per remaining 1k miles metric. This metric was then used to rank cars. Only models with at least 10 model years of production between 2002 and 2021 (20 model years), in production as of the 2020 model year, and with an end-of-life mileage of over 200,000 miles were included for the analysis. A lower end-of-life mileage threshold was used for alternative-fuel vehicles due to their relatively recent introduction. Heavy duty vehicles were also excluded from analysis.

About iSeeCars.com

iSeeCars.com is a car search engine that helps shoppers find the best car deals by providing key insights and valuable resources, like the iSeeCars free VIN check reports and Best Cars rankings. iSeeCars.com has saved users over $360 million so far by applying big data analytics powered by over 25 billion (and growing) data points and using proprietary algorithms to objectively analyze, score and rank millions of new cars and used cars.

This article, Best Used Cars for the Money, originally appeared on iSeeCars.com.