Search

Feds probe electric vehicles after fire in crashed Chevy Volt


U.S. auto safety officials have launched a probe into the safety of electric vehicle batteries after a Chevrolet Volt caught fire weeks after being crash tested.

The probe first reported by Bloomberg News is the broadest investigation so far by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration into the safety of the lithium-ion batteries used in electric vehicles such as the Volt and the Nissan Leaf -- and the same types of batteries expected to power most upcoming EVs and hybrids in the next several years.

NHTSA said in a statement that the fire happened more than three weeks after the Volt was subjected to a side-impact test -- one where it was smashed into a pole at 20 mph. The fire caused some property damage but no injuries; the Volt received a five-star score for occupant safety in the test.

The agency asked every automaker which either has an EV for sale or plans to bring one to market -- including General Motors, Nissan, Ford, Toyota and others -- to explain their procedures for disposing of batteries following a crash, and for tips that might avoid fires or other dangers for tow-truck operators, first responders and anyone else who works with crashed vehicles.

"NHTSA does not believe the Volt or other electric vehicles are at a greater risk of fire than gasoline-powered vehicles," the agency said in a statement. "It is common sense that different designs of electric vehicles will require different safety standards and precautions."

GM spokesman Greg Martin said the company and NHTSA investigated the fire and attempted to recreate it, but were unable to, and that no other crash-tested Volts have caught fire.

"We've subjected the Volt's battery pack alone to 300,000 hours of testing, and we've developed a strong set of safety protocols for battery discharge, handling and disposal," Martin said. "Had those protocols been applied after crash test, this wouldn't have happened."

The case marks the first fire linked to the Volt since it went on sale last December; a house fire earlier this year involving a garage where a Volt was charging was found to have been sparked by faulty wiring. Another recent garage fire with a Volt in North Carolina remains under investigation.

Lithium-ion batteries are generally more stable than traditional car batteries, and can withstand damage such as punctures without sparking or catching fire. But larger electric vehicles such as the Volt and Nissan Leaf carry far more powerful battery packs than hybrids such as the Toyota Prius. Before the Volt was launched, GM conducted several clinics with fire departments and paramedics on how to handle Volt crashes, including how to unplug its batteries and the location of high-voltage wires.

Contact Justin Hyde through email or via Twitter.

 

790 comments

  • bo  •  6 months ago
    A little off subject here, but gotta ask. How much do these batteries cost? I mean you can't just pull into autozone and replace the battery, now can you?
    • Gabby 6 months ago
      Uh no, but they are rated at about 1200 cycles so you could get 150k miles plus out of one. How much does your engine cost? Oh and don't forget that 4-5$ a gallon gas. Also, new technologies are coming out and prices are dropping fast.
    • scott 6 months ago
      How many miles per charge are you giving the Volt, Gabby? 125? Not possible. According to GM, a full battery charge will drive about 35 miles before the gas engine kicks in and charges the battery. Assuming the battery is rated for 1200 cycles, that would mean at 42k miles it would need to be replaced. That's not so good and a far cry from the 150k you suggested.
    • Anonymous 6 months ago
      anywhere from 2k-3k currently
  • William  •  6 months ago
    Why can't they just engineer gas vehicles to get better mileage. Why aren't all cars designed to get over 40 mpg?
    • S. 6 months ago
      $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$

      they can.

      since the 1950's

      BUT the oil companies of America suppressed the carburator technology that made it possible

      NOW, the middle east controls the worlds oil, they dictate what the auto manufacturing industry does.

      didn't you notice how all of a sudden in the last couple of years, suddenly cars are getting fantastic GPM

      because computer tech companies are pioneering electric car tech.

      the electric car will win out in a few morre years
    • Ed Casner 6 months ago
      Where are the diesel hybrids?!? Agree with the conspiracy statement.

      Toyota Starlet.
    • Fred 6 months ago
      physics? - people who believe in all these conspiracies are idiots. How many people would have to agree to suppress the electric car? Now how many people are left on the planet who might profit by introducing an electric car that those conspirators are suppressing?

      So the CEO's of all the car companies in Japan, Korea, US, Germany, Sweden - have all agreed to suppress the electric car so OPEC can make more money - that's perfectly believable.'

      The reason they don't market 3 cylinder turbo diesels in the US is because of US emissions rules, preferences of the american market,etc - just because a product doesn't sell well or isn't profitable in a particular geographic locale doesn't mean its a conspiracy - They don't sell scrapple in San Diego either - but they do in Philadelphia - perhaps its a conspiracy by the mexican restaurants to make sure San Diegians eat lots of egg burittos for breakfast instead of scrapple and eggs.

      Even the russians admit we went to the moon - but not these idiot american conspiracy people - ok - where's my lithium.
  • MouthofWar  •  6 months ago
    2005 VW TDI Golf 60-68 owners average
    • ihateobama 6 months ago
      I don't know why diesels aren't more popular. The Diesel engine is about 30 percent more efficient than gasoline.
    • Robert 6 months ago
      From Germany !!!!!!!!!!
    • Fed Up 6 months ago
      We can thank enviromentalist for slowing down high mileage diesels.
  • Christy  •  6 months ago
    I sell auto parts for a living and this and other electric cars cost a fortune to fix. Just one example is the A/C compressor which will cost you $2500 because its different then a standard car its electric.
    • Robert 6 months ago
      You are more than right, you're telling the scary truth. Most of the repairs will have to take place through the car dealer. We know what they charge in comparison to your local Tire Kingdom. That's why the after market for car repairs and manitenance developed in the first place. The Chevy Revolting is a throwback to dealership monopoly reapirs.
    • Cheese Head 6 months ago
      Oops...this car won't cost you a dime to fix for 10 years.
    • Bama win 6 months ago
      What is the standard warranty? I would take my chances not polluting the air and saving money .. I'm going all electric. You can buy and change that dirty oil along with pumping gas as i pass on by.
  • jason  •  6 months ago
    ill stick to my 92 nissan sentra, 4 cyl, 1.6 lt, but with aftermarket exhaust and air intake and a minor engine tweek im getting 48 mpg. may look like crap but the lil car still goes a heck of a lot further than most 2000 and newer vehicals.
    • J R. 6 months ago
      my 95 honda civic got almost 40 mpg on the hwy. my 2011 aveo get 35 at best seems we went backwards
    • ayercache 6 months ago
      You're so right, a 92 Sentra does look like crap.
    • Bob 6 months ago
      1987 Chevy Sprint Turbo, ugly as hell but got 53 miles to the gallon and was actually fun to drive with the turbo.
  • Tony  •  6 months ago
    The danger of leaking or exploding batteries was mentioned years ago, but for some reason, was never carried by the media. Now before you say it, yes, gasoline is very explosive, but combining this fact with the acid of several batteries makes for a very dangerous situation.
  • babs37  •  6 months ago
    batterys are a health hazard so is the gov.
  • Q10  •  6 months ago
    If it has a battery, thermal runaway will happen. Sooner or later. Any Idea what the Volt
    gets for Mileage when you run the heater, or A/C?,,,,, Just curious.
  • Taxpayer  •  6 months ago
    GM has only "sold" 400 VOLTS to date. Won't cost much for a total recall!
  • Leroy  •  6 months ago
    One commentor is right. I know Ford and GM build better gas mileage cars for foreign countries. So do Toyota, Honda, Hyundai and others. There are some beautiful looking autos made by these companies for sale overseas that get much better mileage than the gas guzzling stuff we get here. Why is that?
  • Impartial Observer  •  6 months ago
    Never trust these "car experts" who sit in front of their laptops. ASK a good mechanic what is a good car to buy ... they'll know which ones are seldom in the shop.
  • Scott  •  6 months ago
    The really scary part of this is that it was a delayed reaction fire well AFTER the crash. THREE WEEKS after!
  • Paladin  •  6 months ago
    Why would anyone buy this GM lemon, 40,000+ price tag 10,000 dollars battery with a life span of 3 years and you can only travel 35 miles on a electric charge.
  • JimmyP  •  6 months ago
    GM should incorporate this feature in their advertising of the Volt. Example:
    This New Electric Volt is really catching on...........FIRE
  • Carlcap1491  •  6 months ago
    What good is an electric car if it only gets 35 miles per charge? An electric car needs to get at least 300 miles per charge and possibly more ASAP! Otherwise, why not go for the hydrogen car? Hydrogen cars can go possibly 800 miles on a full tank.
  • Art in Nevada  •  6 months ago
    What happened to the Geo Metro, which used to get 48 to 50 miles per gallon of gas?
  • Joe G  •  6 months ago
    Wow, now they will have to recall all 147 Volts they have sold so far!
  • Scott  •  6 months ago
    The fires will add a bit to the 'carbon footprint!'
  • o b a m  •  6 months ago
    the enviorment is going to be affected more from a Battery leaking acid all over the place... We'll need Haz-Mat officials on the scene of every accident.
  • 2012 End Of a Nightmare  •  6 months ago
    I am surprised the Volt wasn't on that "flop" list - I thought they sold so FEW of these?

Follow Yahoo! Autos

RESEARCH A CAR

Top Rated

Category: Sedans

More Articles

  • Most improved cars 2012 Marco R. della Cava

    Total Car Score recently released a list of Most Improved Cars for 2012, highlighting eight redesigned automobiles whose improvements helped the models’ scores jump significantly over 2011.

  • Memorial Day means many things to Americans: An opportunity to remember those who've died in service of their country. A chance to get together with friends and relatives. Cookouts. Picnics. Box socials. (They still have those, right?)

  • Take one look at these purpose-built sports cars and you'd expect them to be fast. You would be wrong. Even before we got used to powerful V6 Camrys, these ten rides chosen by Jalopnik readers were the slowest sports cars the world had ever seen.

  • "High performance" and "fuel efficient" need not be mutually exclusive terms, thanks to some truly quick cars that get surprisingly respectable mileage.

  • One of the most widely accepted bits of advice you’ll find presented in practically every consumer magazine as Wisdom From Upon High is a bad idea.